[Highlight] Joel Embiid CLEARLY steps out of bounds with the game on the line. Refs end up missing it and Embiid goes to the line for 2 free throws
Moderator Announcement
Read More »
Replays/alternate angles
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
That’s okay guys, the report after the game will say that the refs made a mistake. That’s all that matters.
I still don’t know why they make those reports public.
And only the last 2 minutes as if the other 46 minutes don’t matter.
All calls matter, but some calls matter more like calls at the end of games matter more because there is less time to make up for the mess up so all of the calls matter yes but it’s most important in the final minutes so that teams don’t have to try to scramble to get back the mistake
Is your suggestion they don’t? It’s an incentive to be better at your job.
What incentive? There’s no blowback. We still talk shit about the same refs for the last decade
the challenges are even worse. Blatant lies even after challenges. it’s just ways to make spreads shave points and tilt games.
It 100% carries into playoff assignments
they should have a relegation system. bad refs relegated to g-league
Lmao no it isn’t it’s placating. If they wanted to hold refs accountable and give them incentive to be better, they’d make them do post game media like they do the players and coaches.
Fuck it. I’m team make them do post game media availability. I’d love explanations for certain calls. Let’s start with how they missed Embiid’s size 8 million shoes being out of the field of play. Give us a season, I’d bet it starts getting cleaned up real quick 😂
This is stupid and would only lead to problems. Referees are stewards of the rules. They’re not there to represent themself. They’re there as a conduit of the league’s rules. Making referees into personalities would be a shitshow that nobody would enjoy. You don’t want refs being faces of the league; you want players and coaches to be that. Could you imagine the witch hunting that would occur when you make refs into individual figures of the league? People already feel like Tony Brothers, Scott Foster, etc. make things too much about themselves. If you gave refs a platform and literally encouraged them to make it about themselves it would be chaos
Especially when plenty of L2Ms are objectively wrong.
Making the refs more well known is a terrible idea.
This is a fantastic idea. The entertainment value alone is worth it.
How’s that working out?
What’s the incentive?
Playoff assignments and public scrutiny.
Is it?
No one has responded to you with an argument why it’s worse to show or better not to show it.
I get that people point out it doesn’t do enough which is valid. But arguing it has no benefit isn’t an argument that it should be taken away. Because it being not public has no benefit either. I don’t understand why people seem to argue that they shouldn’t make it public, if in their eyes, it’s the same thing either way.
It’s only an incentive if it’s tied to consequences for the refs.
Is there evidence it has caused NBA referees to improve at their job? lol
No longer a friend of Bill
in the NHL the refs don’t have to respond to anyone and don’t make any public statements. The players and coaches end up going over the bad penalties and missed calls with the media and half the time no one knows why the refs made a certain call or missed one. The bad calls are becoming more and more common now. There’s 0 accountability.
Yeah, they seem to put the refs in a bit of a quagsire.
well, the refs are always Unaware…
Man of culture.
Underappreciated jok.
Because people complained that there wasn’t any reviewing of umpire decisions.
So they demonstrate there is and so people pivoted back to what they were really complaining about.
Accountability TM
Watch them compensate for it by putting in a phantom missed call on Bucks. I swear the NBA refs are shittiest of all the major sports. They ref based on reputation more than on actual actions on the court.
I swear the NBA refs are shittiest of all the major sports. They ref based on reputation more than on actual actions on the court.
honest question, is there a major sport that doesn’t do this?
Baseball is the only one that comes to mind, and even that I feel like the Umpires are more likely to call a close strike with a star pitching than a rando middle reliever.
Roughing the passer is a huge reputation joke in the NFL and hockey has a lot of enforcer/troublemaker guys who are taking a penalty often even if they do something by accident
this just kind of seems like a reality of sports now
basketball is by far the worst at this, baseball is the best wit he ABS system, and basketball has also had betting rings run by ref’s exposed.
TIM DONAGHY ACTED ALONE
Your baseball comment is out of date with the ABS system.
No other sport I know doesn’t bother calling the game according to the rules of the game because “entertainment” the way basketball does.
NFL refs missed the most obvious pass interference ever, in a playoff game. the league introduced the ability to challenge PI/non PI calls. 24 of 101 calls were overturned. Then they deleted the ability to challenge the next year.
If they called traveling we would have lost damn near every classic highlight dunk.
not that its the same as league play but the mason miller “strikeout” to send the USA to the WBC finals was some certified bullshit
Nah I would say the Premier League refs are by far the worst I’ve ever seen. They even have VAR to review shit and still fuck up major calls all the time. It’s ridiculous.
ufc is wayyy worse
That’s because basketball is the hardest sport to ref. If they didn’t see it they didn’t see it. What would you like them to do? Imagine if someone blew the whistle, gave the ball to the bucks, but turns out he didn’t actually step out of bounds. They’re not going to make a call based on the reaction of the players.
They literally make calls on the reaction of the players all the freaking time.
I’d like them to you know… Be in position to see it.
Spoken like someone who has no idea what reffing is like. “be in position to see it” lol. There’s a million things they are already trying to be in position for. There’s not a ref in sight, meaning they have no clear view of his foot. They don’t have a portal to get them to the baseline instantly to watch his foot.
They are even worse in football (soccer)
I agree about reffing based on reputation but what’s really suspect is how they constantly fall for well known floppers and baiters. Everyone knows who they are and what they do but refs still give them the calls. It seems to me its just a way to control the game to favor their own agenda.
Embiid sure seems fragile for such a big dude.
The most grating part of the L2M report is when they just use the word marginal whenever they feel like it.
I’m not sure this even counts as a refs mistake,there is no ref near the play. One of them probably should have been positioned in the backcourt but either way they’d have to sprint over to that corner to get a clear view, otherwise it would be a pure guess for any of them make the call.
This is a league mistake imo, a play like this could be reviewed by the league and informed to the officials in seconds.
Half the court saw him step out lol, it isn’t like the refs were a hundred yards away.
You realise this is in the backcourt right? It’s pretty much impossible to see from where the refs were at. Especially when Embiid’s shoes are the same color as the line.
Ref will give the moral victory to bucks later on. It’s meaningless but the bucks will feel better. Well, not really and they will probably feel the opposite. But the Last Two Minute Report will means… something? I really dont know why we bother with these fucking reports if it’s ultimately of no use and the aggrieved party will feel much worse with late and utterly useless vindication.
Useless reporting.
After bets have been paid out.
I love ref accountability in the NBA
I don’t see any refs in the video, would they even be able to see this?
Reading that, I had to make sure I wasn’t on r/soccer. Probably the two most badly ref’d sports right now
Trust the refs
Funny thing is there are no refs in this video
Nooo actually he had the ball spinning on his right hand while he stepped out and hadn’t gathered the ball within four steps or 7 feet of the fourth row while wearing socks with one inch of his knee. So actually it was legal. Learn the modern rules pal.
This is the type of thing AI could easily eliminate so the refs could focus more on irrationally calling/not calling the new flopping techs.
thank goodness that cleared everything up
PHEW. Take that, refs!
Just watching that clip I am genuinely trying to figure out where the closest ref is to the play. Where the hell are they??
Moral victories win playoffs
It’s only fixed if the refs tell us they’ve had sleepless nights though
Should have had a challenge. Used both.
Shouldn’t need to challenge a call as obvious as this.
But I would probably defend the team I support in a situation like this as well, so I can’t blame you.
I mean, sixers should have lost, full stop. I would be pissed if I was a Bucks fan. But the refs were far away (full court) from the action and didn’t see it. The near buzzer beater always gets reviewed, that’s in the rules.
This is a clear out of bounds
You’re out of bounds
shouldn’t need a challenge if the refs were competent
Even if they had one, you have to challenge an existing call. There would have been no call to challenge. Unless they challenged the foul call and on review they correctly said embiid stepped out of bounds before the foul?
I get that it sucks that there’s a blown call, but what human would be able to see this?
That’s why you keep your challenges until you know you’ll win or late in the game. It’s hard to keep and eye on the top half of a play and the ball carriers feet at the same time tbf.
All 76ers flairs defending this 🤣
I get it, I would probably do the same for the Lakers, but it’s still hilarious.
I know your homerism has deactivated any brain activity you may have had, but you can’t challenge a non call. Then having their challenge would change nothing here.
You can challenge the foul and they would’ve seen it was oob…. Duh
Except they literally just say that the out of bounds is non pertinent to whatever you challenged, similar to what they did in the recent Raptors game vs the Knicks… Duh
Always coordinate your shoe color with the baseline. Pro move.
Belichick used to tell Patriots players to wear gloves matching the color of their opponents jerseys to hide the hold lol
i think you cant do that any, more for this reason, black and white might be ok, but other than that you have to wear your team colors.
So the Raiders are really spoiled for choice, then
Well, it’s the Raiders though. I’ll allow it lol
I remember in college ball they used to require neutral grey gloves. Not sure when that changed exactly.
He couldn’t stand Edelman wearing red gloves, too.
Nets have a ring if KD wears black shoes
Lmao real
I know you’re just joking but the Nets still would’ve had to play two more rounds that year had KD’s shot counted as a three, plus I think both Harden and Kyrie were banged up at that point
Kyrie would have came back to the round and Harden would have healed bit more. Nets were destroying bucks before Giannis injured Kyrie
I mean they’d definitely have a shot at the championship, I’m just pushing back on the notion that KD’s toe was the only difference between a ring and no ring that year
Nope, Spider-Ref says he only gets one.
Reminds me of the TD in the Raiders/Pats game that tied it before Mac Jones got sent to the shadow realm on the fuckass lateral.
KD took it a step further back then and just walked into the front row without any camouflage.
It would actually be the opposite, co-ordinate your shoe colour to the colour of the court just inside the baseline.
It’s harder to detect a slight undulation in a consistent block of colour than it is to see if there is a gap in the matching colour of shoe and baseline.
Meaning we know for a fact he stepped out because we can’t see the color of the court inside the line.
I’ll always remember the Broncos blocking a kick and returning it for a game winning TD and they couldn’t rule him out of bounds due to his white cleats and it wasn’t clear if he was out or not.
You’re thinking of the Knicks game where OG was guarded by Johnson, they were both wearing similar shoe color and Johnson stepped out, but Foster called it as OG stepping out. It was in the playoffs.
But Knicks obviously got the last laugh there.
Less effective when you cover the entire red line with your foot and now are stepping on the blue paint too lmao
Y’all remember the time KD was out of bounds when he was on the Warriors? I mean like way out of bounds
Kd was out there dancing in a different county. Rockets got the dub but my God that shit was egregious.
I genuinely believe that he was so far out the refs got confused and thought the out of bounds line was the next color change 4 feet out.
Ngl that out of bounds was so bad, that I thought the game was fixed lmao. That shit was EGREGIOUS
It’s one of the funniest NBA clips because the announcers didn’t see it live so they are all “let’s see the replay” and start counting his steps and KD just keeps going further and further out of bounds to their disbelief lol
Way worse than the Embiid miss. The announcers counting steps in disbelief, peak comedy.
Harden had the biggest ‘ball don’t lie’ moment right after
James Harden A FLAMETHROWER.
Should have been a 4 point play too.
You wanna know who was on the floor w/ Harden for that last shot?
PJ Tucker, Austin Rivers, Gerald Green, and Danuel House Jr
against Klay Thompson, Andre Iguodala, Kevin Durant, Draymond Green, and Kevon Looney
Everyone knew where the ball was going, there wasn’t even a second option on the court. Over Draymond and Klay. Very cathartic shot for Rockets fans (although doesn’t heal the wound)
The league conspired to help GSW win that game and Harden said fuck no
thank you for reminding me of this, somehow more ridiculous than I remember. Took 3 steps and was a good 18 inches out of bounds lmao and it was 30 seconds left in a tie OT game https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpAk2tABTcA
This is legitimately the most egregious (obviously on purpose) missed call ever right? Other than maybe that NFL playoff game (Rams Saints I think) where the dude just blew up the receiver like 8 seconds before the ball got to him and no PI was called
Yes it’s absolutely the most insane missed call ever in any sport. It’s so objective and also so egregious.
It directly led to one of the greatest regular season shots ever though.
It’s the worst missed call ever yes. Has to be. The out of bounds rule takes root in factuality and not in any way open to interpretation as there’s a line on the court for everyone to see.
“Out, out, and …out! How on Earth could you miss that?”
No one that saw that would ever forget it. That ref should have lost his job.
Harden still clutched it too
Out of bounds? Bro was watching from the stands
With the ref right in front of him
He was closer to the locker rooms than to the court and the ref was right there.
That’s the first thing that came to my mind too when I saw that LMAO KD with both feet planted out of bounds lol
KD was in the cheap seats he was so far out
That was 100 times more egregious, he was like 2 feet out of bounds lol.
What made that worse is that they were obviously trying to make the warriors win that game. Waiving off Harden 3s like they would do based off some ridiculous reason. Then Harden and co winning that game anyways was so sweet.
The worst missed call of all time.
Literally the only time I’ve ever cheered for Harden in my life lol.
It’s what I think back to any time this happens.
wait til you see the travel on harden the play before lmao
What does that have to do with this
Yeah I can’t think of even one similarity
Unironically they waited for the whistle to come, which made them foul a little later and Tyler didn’t release his shot in time
Yep, this screwed the Bucks on multiple levels.
Herro making that shot at the end would have been crazy. Instead, they take it away, and it’s a crappy ending to an otherwise fun game.
It always funny the kind of foul you see in those situations, they barely touch the player here but they still whistle because everyone knows he’s trying to foul. But during regular plays in the game they would never count that as a foul, there’s way more contact than that on almost every actions during the game without fouls.
Shouldn’t have taken the dribble
That was the only way he got a clean look at it
I mean you have 1.5 seconds- you gotta know you don’t really have time for a dribble.They definitely got robbed by the missed call tho
He needed the dribble to get space. Without the space it’s a contested shot that could just have easily been blocked.
The dribble was the right move, the main issue here is the refs just not recognizing where Embiid was standing on the previous sequence
Refs on a hot streak, 2 game deciding calls/no calls this week
bucks got robbed lmao
How wasn’t this reviewable? They do 3pt line review minutes after.
theres no call to review
I’ve seen them completely take a 3 pointer off the scoreboard like 7 possessions later after a timeout cause a player stepped out of bounds before they shot. But this isn’t gonna be looked at with a foul occurring seconds after? NBA has to figure the review system out.
should implement replay assist like the NFL
Because there’s a rule that let’s the officials use replay to check every 3 pointer during the next break. There’s no rule for this situation, it’s not like the refs can do whatever they want.
Although I just learned if the Bucks had challenged the foul then the refs could also look for out of bounds in that situation.
They did it to us in game 7 against Boston in 2022. They did it silently during a commercial break several possessions later. Took a 3 off the board bc they said he stepped out in a game we had possession with the shot clock off down 2. Still haven’t seen a conclusive video showing he was out
Well yeah because they review all 3-pointers because it’s a shot where the points change depending on the position of your foot. There’s no mechanism of reviewing a real-time no-call unless there is a reviews call in the act of it.
What about on 3s they will go back and take points.
Something happened for there to be a challenge, a field goal was made
Same reason they can’t add back points on uncalled goal tends but they can review called goaltends. Rules don’t allow to review non calls.
If the Bucks challenged the foul then they could have looked at the proximate out of bounds and called it. But no challenge left
i think for those the refs usually signal to check if it was a 3 or not then they will review it next stoppage, it’s usually for ones they don’t see or are unsure about, you’ll see them do something with their hand usually on the shot, maybe to alert the scorekeepers or something to have video or something? not sure on the protocol but they definitely do something
All review rules are made up. All of them. Make up another rule that you can review this. Done.
Oh pls they could have reviewed it during a timeout just like how a few years ago in the playoffs they erased a Max Strus 3 ages after he made it during a dead ball.
Only if your name is Max Strus
You can’t review non-calls. That’s why when there’s a goaltending called you can challenge it, but if there is a goaltending and it isn’t called then you can’t.
The refs can’t just review the play, and the Bucks didn’t have a challenge. If they did they just challenge the intentional foul and get the possession off of the out of bounds that takes place beforehand.
You could review the foul and the moments leading up to it. I’ve seen refs review things even without challenges in the last minutes of a game
Bucks were out of challenges, wasted one earlier.
They had money on the sixers
You can’t review an action that doesn’t stop the game.
1 zillion IQ move by Jo to wear red sneakers
Refs were seemingly blind in the last few seconds. LeBron was fouled intentionally like 3 times and they just didn’t call it for some reason
Justice for Josh Huestis some 10 odd years ago.
https://youtu.be/2zxYHRwx4CE?is=tgXF7WcgFKlSXaG2
This play haunts me. The sideline ref is literally looking at his foot! Insane
That is really great picture quality for 10 years ago.
You’re surprised that we had 720p in 2016?
It’s better quality that I usually see on YouTube from 10 years ago.
Agree. Tyler herro for Giannis is pretty asinine
We can’t even identify the robbery here, there was just literally not enough refs to see him step out of bounds. You don’t even see a ref in the whole lowlight.
I would agree, but more so, if somehow the turnover results in a tie that would have gone to overtime and somehow the Bucks won, I would say the teams that are actually competing against the 76ers for 1st place are the real ones that were robbed.
still would’ve won??
If embiid going out of bounds was called herro would’ve had the time to get the shot off and embiid wouldn’t have took those 2 ft to add to the lead
How do you people understand that the game would look nothing like it did if Embiid’s out of bounds was called. That entire sequence leading to Herro’s shot would have looked wildly different
if herro hits the same shot they win by 2 cuz the sixers wouldve only been up 1 without the free throws
Yea idk why I completely blanked on embiid taking those 2 ft
Anyone with a brain knows bucks weren’t winning in ot
That’s cause I was wrong, if it was called properly embiid would’ve never been fouled and wouldn’t have got those 2 ft to extend the lead. The bucks would’ve won off herros shot
Dumb comment. Tyler herro made a shot at the end just didn’t get it off in time.. down 1 changes everything
bucks were down 3 with 1.5 seconds, and ended up being .5 seconds away from sending it to overtime
how can you possibly think it’s guaranteed they couldn’t have won the game being down 1 point with 3 seconds left?
Smartest Philly fan lmao
?? Bucks get the ball with 3 seconds left down 1 if they call it?
Honest question. If the Bucks had a challenge, could they challenge the foul on Herro (even though it was intentional) to have the refs call an out of bounds when looking at the entire play? Not sure what the rules are for that
Yes. You can challenge the foul itself and they are allowed to look at everything that happens in that play.
And then the refs call that “separate from the play” and ignore it as a result.
Like they did in the Knicks and raptors game when Landry shamet pushed down RJ Barrett to get free for a layup. The refs called and 1, play was challenged but they deemed the offensive foul to get shamet free as non pertinent to the play 🤣🤣🤣
Yeah that’s what I’m referring to lol
Exactly. There’s no real recourse for a missed call like that even if Stevie Wonder could have seen it
I dont believe Stevie Wonder would’ve seen that since he is blind
I don’t think they can since it’s an out of bounds violation meaning everything that comes after that violation is rendered null.
It would be up to the refs. Could go either way due to the gap between the foot on the line and the shove.
I mean, you could also make the argument that a foul that is “separate from the play” would also render everything that happens after null, but apparently no.
So waning minutes of the game if an approximate off ball foul or occurrence, defense should intentionally foul to trigger a wider review
They added that rule after the Wolves got screwed out of it not existing at the time
It’s rule 14-III-a-7:
If an instant replay review of a called foul is triggered by a Challenge, the on-court crew chief will review the video to evaluate whether the foul being challenged was correctly called.The on-court crew chief may also review the video to determine only the following other matters:…If an offensive player was fouled while in possession of the ball, whether the player who was fouled committed a boundary line violation either just prior to or after the fou
“Just prior to” is still going to be up to the refs, depending on their feelings about the delay before the foul making the step on the line proximate or not.
Yes. I think any challenge on the foul there would get the proximate plays reviewed at the same time, i.e. stepped out of bounds before the foul = Bucks ball
Yes. It is an proximate violation since it takes place before the foul and they would have given the Bucks possession.
It’s essentially the same as the VJ foul being changed to an offensive foul. An approximate foul that took place before the called one.
Proximate*
Thank you.
Why are you people being wholesome? It’s disturbing on this sub.
I thought they couldnt challenge no-calls?
The foul on embiid was the call, they can look for things around that /before (proximity) and would have seen the out of bounds.
Actually, hard to say, due to the amount of time between the step and the foul.
Gray area based on refs interpretation of “proximate”.
yes, that would come into play
why do that when you can just wait for the 2 min report the next day
Why didnt the refs review to see the exact time of the foul. Ig they add 2 more tenths you get overtime and Herro likely goes for 63
Clear as day but my team sucks so who really cares lol
Man I really thought you guys would get a second win before us lol watch us blow out the Celtics tonight😂😭
Celtics by 3 dozens incoming
no JT, DWhite, or Mitch tonight; take your best shot tonight big boys
Incoming Leaky Black legacy game
oh that is such a crazy comment lmfao. my condolences. teams are gonna want precious achiuwa starting dec 15!
Won by one, but still good shit
Yea that was some good shit. Keegan Murray from the top ropes lol
You ain’t blowing out the Celtics lol
Win maybe but not a blowout. Prob not now that u posted this tho
To be fair, ref isn’t anywhere near the ball. Difficult to make a call, which happens. It’s not like I could tell in real time, without the slow-motion.
Because you don’t want to be in the bottom 3 spots of the draft (worse odds). Sucks.
Dw I guarantee you very few actually cares about the Bucks, but rather this makes it easier to pile on the 76ers
I didn’t see anything
Challenge or not, it shouldn’t be up to the coaches to officiate the game.
It’s kinda crazy that the team needs to initiate a challenge on something so clear at a time in the game so crucial
I hate that they used to be able to review this and other stuff in the last 2 minutes regardless of challenges or whatever, but they stopped because people with short attention spans complained about the delays.
If they wanted, they could have a VAR situation where a separate video referee checks these things in 15 seconds and radios it to the officials on the floor, instead of them standing six minutes in front of a monitor.
Honestly insane that this isn’t a thing.
That’s not even why. It was the Ayton alley-oop game in the conf finals against the clippers (it was 1-0 for the suns before that game with home court; clips lost in 6, and this might have been why). Suns had the ball with 0.4 or 0.5 seconds left, and the refs reviewed it and made it 0.9. They took so long to review that the suns wrote up a whole play and won the game because of that. Given the area where they were inbounding and the time left, the suns would have probably lost that game without the practical free time out. RIP for the clippers again. The NBA makes a bunch of new rules after something gets abused in one playoffs. Some of them are good, some are iffy, and some are bad. Other include the proximate foul after kyrie fouled either conley or mcdaniels and went out on the t-wolves player, but, back then you couldn’t call a foul on that and you could only review the out of bounds and they lost the game by a possession. In response, the NBA created the proximate foul and reviewing calls that had unfair fouls on the possession. Also, in the Rockets vs Warriors series, Brooks was slapping Steph’s injured hand, so they made a rule where it makes it a foul if you do that, even for some marginal contact.
People seeking entertainment from entertainment product somehow upset when it wasn’t entertaining
The fact that the refs can’t look at this and change it to the correct call is absolutely absurd
The refs just this week stopped active play in the last 2 minutes of a Wolves game to see if the ball touched the rim or not for a shot clock violation. They didn’t even have to stop play to check this.
There’s certain things they are allowed to stop play for and checking if the shot clock should reset is one of them. There has to be a rule that let’s the refs stop play to review and there isn’t one for out of bounds.
You’re probably right, but it’s dumb that they would allow it in a situation that stops play but not be able to check for anything when the ball is dead.
They can check for stuff when the ball is dead, they just can’t check out of bounds unless it’s challenged. But of course you can’t challenge it if they never make a call.
That’s why during a game when they can’t tell who it went off of they just do a jump ball instead of a review.
Ah, I believe that’s what I was thinking of, thanks for clarifying!
Well yeah, because the 24 second clock was triggered so obviously they have to review. It’s dfferent when no call was made
This is the real issue here. The refs were in the frontcourt and had absolutely no way of seeing this. They can’t guess and call him out, and they’re not allowed to just look up at the screen and change a call. The NBA needs to figure out some way of dealing with these situations whether it’s the replay center triggering a review or something else.
Right? I thought there was a final 2 minute review protocol for possible out-of-bounds calls, maybe I’m mistaken?
lmao what? That was a review for out of bound calls already made and regardless They got rid of that 5 years ago after that Suns-Clippers clusterfuck in the playoffs.
No call was made here
About damn time this gets posted. Fuck you referee
This post would have 1000+ upvotes if it were a more popular team.
Embiid plus the Lebron Sixers are pretty popular for haters
It’s a recipe for hater of the year awards. I’m still shocked you guys kept coming so hard late in the 4th. I thought with a minute left and up 6, you guys would miss a a three and that would be game but you just kept hitting the 3’s. I don’t understand how you only have 1 win or did you guys just play us really hard?
Take it easy buddy he’s not gonna fuck your wife
I always see this comment on a post that’s currently #1 on a sub
It’s literally only been posted for half an hour, chill out on the hyperbole for a second, eh?
It had been up for 4 minutes when they complained lmao
dawg you posted this comment 1 minute after the post
Oh look at that! It now has well over 1000 upvotes! Crazy that patience comes in handy sometimes
Sensitive ass lmao, just wait
I was thinking it was so egregious, they might remove it like 4 times. This wasn’t a misinterpretation of the rules
Which referee are you mad at? They’re all (in position) 50+ feet away
Damn could of gotten the second win of the season 😣😣
could of
Could HAVE
These refs this year are so horrible
Said every year
This year?
They are significantly bad this year. Like this is just insane to miss
They missed it because they werent there,which is different than seeing it and not calling it, like the KD situation.
Refs are always bad, people just feel it more because of gambling.
lol I don’t gamble. I just watch. Refs not being there is apart of them being bad…
The old ones are generally bad, but the new ones they have are a new level of dogshit
What’s crazy is, I don’t see a ref anywhere in this whole clip. wtf they at lol
Don’t worry, it’ll get better as the League and Players deepen their ties to sport’s bettering and prediction markets.
The challenge is how much do we let the refs get involved until it gets to be like the NFL where no one can actually define a “catch” because it’s been sliced and diced by refs so frequently over the years. You can’t just cheer on a big play in the NFL without first checking for penalties. This was a missed call, but such is life. Over the course of a season they even out.
People say this a lot but the refs get catches or drops correct the vast majority of the time especially on review. You can always point to a couple missed calls here and there but they’re right most of the time
Sure but the complexity of how a catch is defined requires them to scan, review, confirm, way too long and often. That’s what the NBA could easily become. Which would suck.
NFL catch rules are actually pretty easy to decipher and the refs virtually always get it right - the problem is that people don’t understand the rule, not the refs misinterpreting it.
I disagree. The problem is the constant checking, validating, challenging, etc. It just takes forever because the rules are so overly complex. It takes away from the fun of watching the sport. Which is the only reason to be a fan - it should be fun.
The problem isn’t the rule, the problem is that it’s hard to tell exactly what happened and if you prioritize speed over accuracy, you end up with exactly what happened in this game
Yep. They seem to have an agenda
That’s why you wear red shoes 👠
Also there’s no place like home…
Man if we weren’t dog shit this year I’d be pissed lol
Why is nobody asking WTF is he even doing? It’s like he thought he could just run to the locker room. If you’re trying to kill clock you run in circles to avoid the foulers. I get that Embiid is slow but it’d be better than running to the corner like this.
Red shoes red line, thats tactical
Refs stole this one. Embarrassing run from the refs lately
That’s not even bringing up the 37-18 FT disparity. Like i know the Bucks foul, not denying Sixers earned most of their shots, but Burries getting 1 FT on 20 shots is wild.
Sixers strategy is to not foul a lot though, multiple times they just let the opposing players walk up to the basket
Did you watch the game? There may have been two or three questionable calls for each team, but the Bucks were basically gifting fouls to the Sixers and the Sixers gave the Bucks open lanes all game. I’m not surprised about the FT disparity at all
Refs literally stole 5 points from the Bucks off bullshit calls
Nah yall just shat the bed in the second half
Brings back some NBA memories
That one was more egregious because not only was Durant completely out of bounds, but the ref was right there looking at it. At least with Embiid, no ref had LOS
Yeah not nearly on the same level
In an interview after the game, Durant said that the refs were trash in that game, so he knew he could get away with that lol
Yea games like this ruin the immersion. Numerous refs saw it but nobody called it. They didnt need to huddle together to decide to make the call. The refs knew not to call KD out of bounds.
Sometimes you know the clip before even having to click 😭
Knew exactly what this was gonna be.
Nah KD was actually inbounds
Now, I understand why it got missed. There’s no ref on the baseline to see over the line.
But where the hell is the lead ref?
It’s stupid not having the trail referee in the backcourt for situations like this. They added the rule to allow a backcourt inbound but the refs are all on the frontcourt.
IMO, they should have the reserve ref come out of the locker room for the last 2 minutes of close games.
Edit: i forgot reserve refs are only in the playoffs.
Its tough, just cause trail and center referee have to rotate depending on what side of the court the ball is on. Having the trail referee all the way behind half court with how much the ball moves around would have them having to move way too far
Everyone’s on the other end of the court (where the play came from).
Shockingly refs are not as fast as pro athletes who know the play
This is why we have 3 referees. (Former referee myself)
The trail ref typically is holding out closer to the half court Line behind the ball, when a change of possession occurs the trail ref rotates to the opposing baseline and becomes lead referee. Its a pretty big fuck up for the lead referee to just not be there.
Ridiculous. You clearly weren’t a ref. The trail ref is totally out of position here. You think refs shouldnt be in a position to get across half court? What happens if theres a steal and contested layup? No ones expected to be there?
Nope, the trail ref was out of position and extremely lazy.
It was a frontcourt OOB play throw into the back corner. There’s never going to be a ref with eyes on that baseline. If he had a good look at it he would’ve been hilariously out of position
Just unlucky blind spot
Yeah, best case scenario that ref would be at like the FT line. Still out of position to see the baseline well
The solution is one more ref on the court.
Whenever I say “we need more officials not less’ people down vote it into oblivion, but this is why. If there were more refs you wouldn’t have all the officials on the other end and screened out of the play
1 ref on all 4 sides of the court, out of bounds, running up and down and side to side. then 2 running up and down the court with the players
Yeah, make them swap locations every quarter just to balance the cardio.
This is what I envision too
Might well have 6. 4 on the baseline, 2 at midcourt
Should at least have a seperate group just watching the out of bounds cameras. Would cover stuff like this without adding any more bodies to the floor.
The most ethical use of Ai. Computer vision for out of bounds
you don’t even need ai for this. this could be and has been solved in other sports using shit that was developed decades ago.
Having a functioning sensor is not AI jfc yall just say anything
Hurr durr AI slop posters are so fucking annoying
Blaming everything on AI distracts from abuses and real issues. But redditors gotta be angry
Optimizing life, curing cancer, and out of bounds violations 🥹
This is what the video review is for. To spot howlers at the end of close games. I don’t know how this didn’t get overturned.
Yeah I thought they can choose to review last 2 minutes. Unless they wanted one team to win there’s no reason it shouldn’t have been overturned
No, that rule was only in the event of an actual out of bounds call and they got rid of it 5 years ago because it was making games take too long. In this case, the only way this would have ever been overturned is if they reviewed the foul, and even then that only happns with a challenge; if the refs reviewed every single foul in the last 2 minutes that would be even worse than the out of bound reviews they already gt rid of. I believe the only exception is block/charges
Why can’t they do what the NFL does and have someone reviewing for egregious errors (especially for out of bounds plays) and do an expedited review? This basically decided the game. It’s obviously important enough to get it correct.
This. If you know they blew a call immediately then correct it!!
they only review change of position calls (out of bounds) and line scoring (foot on the line or not, or shot clock).
This one isn’t on any of those guidelines so coach needs to challenge it. Which sucks
They should do it soccer style and have two line judges. Each watches a baseline and one of side of the court exactly for this.
It’s plays like this where I don’t understand why NY can’t just quickly overturn it like the NFL does.
How many are currently on the floor? And do they all have the same ability to make same calls? (Ie in hockey there are refs and there are linesmen)
Just have sensors on the floor. Steps out of bounds it lights up. Can even have sensors that can tell if you traveled or not.
More refs wouldn’t make a difference. Remember there was a ref right in front of KD when he dribbled out of bounds that one time and didn’t call it. Nba refs are one of the worst in American sports. Which is saying alot because refs in NFL,MLB and college football are dogshit too.
I hope they design an AI program to continuously review the 10 different camera angles and overrule the refs when appropriate in real time. Eventually this will be faster than the whole challenge system.
Literally as simple as adding chips to the ball for ball out of bounds and cameras or IR blasters to all 4 corners of the court
but they don’t 😐
How do sensor chips in the ball fix plays like this? You can have the ball outside the line but the feet in, or the feet out and the ball inside. Either way chips aren’t giving you a proper reading based only on ball position.
I agree and have been saying this for years. 4 officials each game. They are positioned in a square at each corner of the half court and each official is responsible for making calls in their quadrant. Then when possession changes the officials close to half court run to the opposite baseline and the baseline officials run to half court. There would be way fewer missed calls this way. Only problem is the league probably doesn’t want to pay for 25% more refs.
I make a similar argument with the NFL; we need more reviews, not less. Game length means jack shit to me if it’s tainted by clearly incorrect calls.
I’d rather watch a game that takes 20 minutes longer than usual and know that the calls were correct than shorter with blown calls.
Every play or possession needa to be reviewed
I don’t care if games take 8 hours
“More refs”. Bud this shit is rigged. You can’t be serious.
I always get hate for saying the same thing. Like the reason they didn’t call this wasn’t because they missed it, they didn’t call it on purpose. I’m not saying it’s malicious or anything, I just don’t think they want to let the game end like that against the bucks.
Or you just have an AI review these out of bounds calls. Same with goaltending
You don’t even need AI, that tech has already existed for years
Holy shit bro prolly thinks a level also needs AI to work too huh lol
Relax fam
The Hawk-Eye system used in tennis was implemented more than twenty years ago and is still in use today.
refs are just corrupt and biased.
We have cameras.
Everyone can see it.
No need for having 10 officials when 10 cameras can already see everything.
One of the referees clearly has an assignment to follow the end line. Simply they did not do their job and it should be reprimanded
Why do we need refs for this, cant they use the same tech from tennis?
2 more refs gotta show up for the final 5 mins
Yup. It’s baffling that basketball and soccer still insist on having a certain number of refs simply because that’s how it’s always been
In all seriousness, how the hell does anyone complaining on this thread expect any of the refs to see this split second incident at the wrong end of the court from where the play started?
Can’t do that if you’re Embiid, we definitely got lucky.
Apparently he can.
Ya, staying inbounds matter lol
I laughed so hard, it’s like Lebron told Embiid to run like hell and go piss in a corner, and Embiid did exactly that but somehow fucked it up. Feels like a bizarre scheme only veterans would come up with
Oh my God that’s a horrific fucking call
Best refs in the world at it again.
This is one of those things where I feel like the structure of how games are officiated is a problem.
This clearly shows he stepped out of bounds. But because the referees didn’t see it at the time and didn’t call it, they just have to pretend this didn’t happen.
Anybody reasonable would say that a referee should be able to look at this and say “oh yes, the footage shows he stepped out of bounds, so it’s Milwaukee ball.” But instead we have a system where the game moves forward in a way that everyone in the arena knows is incorrect because of what? Ego?
NFL has actually done a decent job of this with the replay assist. Anything that’s incredibly obvious they’ll just radio in and change the call without a challenge or official replay process.
It works better in football because there’s a break after every play that allows time to review. Would be much harder to implement in a continuous sport like basketball
But there was a foul called on this play and a stop in action. An automatic “ref challenge” or replay assist would see this and get the call right.
I think every foul in the last 2 minutes of a close game should be automatically reviewed. Look at a L2M report and how much is missed. Why can’t the league catch this stuff in real time?
Yeah in this specific instance it would’ve worked I was just saying in general why it would be much more difficult to implement. Also if all fouls under two minutes were automatically reviewed games would take three hours and people would lose interest
Last 2 minutes take forever in basketball already.
Exactly so why add more time?
They take away a point for an incorrect 3 all the time.
Rugby started doing this years ago too. It was a bit clunky at first but it works much better now.
I just think it’s completely crazy that the refs can call something one way, they can show a replay for everyone in the arena that it is clearly, 100%, no grey area about it just plain wrong - and even though the refs can also see this, the game moves forward off of the incorrect call. Just look at the replay happening right in front of you and change your decision. This shouldn’t be controversial.
People will bitch about that too. Just look at how fans reacted to the officials making the right call of an interception in the Broncos Panthers game after fucking up and letting the Panthers run another play
Text book use of a review. Stepping on a line for 3s or out of bounds.
Review center just speaks to arena the correct call, takes 20 seconds.
wait… so the refs cant overturn a missed call or things like that like it happens on football? unless it is a challenge from a team
Completely broken by design
It quickly becomes a lot of people when you consider there’s a live crowd who has to be able to follow along between all the moving bodies, but an extra ref at each end of the floor who always stays behind the baseline would solve a lot in terms of getting calls correctly.They’d easily get a missed call like this and they would always have good position on fast breaks as they’re not running up and down the court.
Not quite KD out of bounds level bad but oof bucks robbed.
I’m wondering why there was no ref on that side of the court in the first place when they have the ability to pass past half court.
This is the only question that needs to be answered. Everything else is obvious.
It was inbounded on the other side of the court and they expected him to get fouled? There are 4-5 seconds left at the point hes past halfcourt. It’s really Herro’s fault for not just fouling but he tried to force a turnover. He succeeded, but it was in a bad spot where he’s not going to get any help.
Unless you think the refs are Usain Bolt, they are not getting from their normal inbound spots to the other baseline in 3~ seconds
The ball is just as likely to go in the backcourt as the front court there. So why are literally none of them there? What if there’s a steal and contested layup on the other end which is entirely feasible? They just forego being able to call fouls?
It was horrendous positioning by the refs and even worse laziness.
Refs have certain formations depending on where the ball is. Since it started in the front court, they have someone next to the in bounder, someone baseline front court, and someone on the other side front court.
Makes no sense to have someone baseline front court. Sixers are not looking to score. The ball is more likely to end up in the backcourt then near the rim.
What if theres a steal and contested layup? Refs are just out of the play? Makes no sense.
1 ref should have been closer
Reminds me of the KD one but this is still unacceptable to not call
At least the rockets won that game (with an insane harden shot) but that one was way worse. Whole body was out of bounds lmao.
Whole foot out
The NBA is not that different from WWE.
Unserious league
Refs have a shrine to Embiid
Perfect example of why NBA should have replay assist
Should not need to challenge something like this. Get it right.
Not for subjective things like fouls etc but out of bounds, goaltend etc