Kenny Atkinson after James Harden’s 51-point game: “We’ve got to appreciate this guy. This guy is top 10 of all-time.”
Yes of the 50 guys who are in the top 10 harden should be one of them
Analytically
and its not even close
He might have meant that he’s top 10 all time in scoring. Hes currently number 9 and has a shot to pass Jordan if he plays a few more years
This is his coach. Obviously he’s going to glaze him and pump him up by calling him top 10. Not everything a coach says about their players is going to be based on 100% irrefutable facts.
This is how half this sub sounds when they glaze luka
Maybe top-10 all time active players?
Not top 10 active players in the league, but take the all time ranking and cross out anyone who retired already, maybe that way Harden go up enough to reach top 10?
Top 51 Top 12 guys - Bill Simmons
How many faces can we fit on our Mt Rushmore?
One guy has the Janus piece
Top 10 in playoff turnovers thats for sure.
Absolutely
For scoring. All time maybe 25 if you’re being nice
10 per position?
I mean… he’s a clear Hall of Famer. Top ten is nuts but what is his current coach supposed to say?
Harden is an all time great. Not sure there’s any need to go deeper than that.
so let’s hear an honest rating of him all time. top 30?
Top 25-30 is fair
That’s a fair one. There’s like a top 12 crowd and a top 20ish crowd that ends with guys like Robinson, Barkley.
After that it’s again a crowd with the likes of Wade, Kawhi if you ignore the fact he doesnt play. Feels like he belongs in that crowd.
I like Dean Wade, but I still think he is outside of the top 50 all time players imo
easily top 51 imo
Dean Wade or Dwyane Wade? lol.
bro dwade and kawhi clear harden what are we saying lmao
Aint no dwade lower than Barkley or Robinson
you’re nuts
Decade is behind Barkley with fucking ease.
Hes a top 5 sg so probably top 30 yea
He should be in the top 30-50 imo.
I agree, I think he’s probably in the 30’s. If he had gotten over the hump while he was a Rocket he’d likely be much higher though.
I don’t think it’s fair to hold that against him. He went against an absolute super team (KD warriors) and went toe to toe with them.
I will die on the hill that Harden deserved a ring during his prime and it would absolutely change how people evaluate him. And I’m a Mavs fan!
This is his range. Any higher is delusional dick-riding.
Somewhere around 25 prob
25 is rough, I think I can easily find 25 FMVP + MVP with titles that went over the hill.
In his defense, the Hill was the late Spurs and Warriors dynasty and Peak LeBron so it makes it hard to see it clearly where he can stand but probably about the same as Charles Barkley
I checked some lists and it seems like a lot of people who know more than me put him around 30. He’s #9 scoring all time, so the main things holding him out of a comfortable top 25 spot are well documented. A lot of it is opinion based anyway. If he ended up on a chip team, even if he underperformed that season he would be looked at entirely differently.
Maybe cracks 25, but no title means a lot.
Correct. For example Nash is an all time great and I don’t see him in top 20 discussions
Correct. wade / dirk tier will always clear harden / nash / melo / AI / barkley by virtue of actually becoming champions and they deserve it. anyone against can argue with a wall
Nash is great but he’s really not that close to Harden.
I do.
Harden has double the 1st teams Nash had
Its not just no title
He is a playoff bum
It’s hilarious that morons say this when Harden is actually a good playoff performer and his best teammate in Houston was old injured CP3 lmao
Harden faced insane teams in the West from OKC KD/WB, early champ Warriors then KD Warriors, 60+ win Spurs, bubble Lakers and never lost a series as an underdog while posting great playoff stats
Did he have some bad playoff games? Yes but this is what’s wrong with braindead NBA fans, that 2017 Rockets team is better than half of the championship teams even more but lost to the most stacked team ever
He’s not top 30 😂
18-22
Top 20 with a ring
Maybe he meant top ten scorer since it was about a high point game?
Somewhere in the 30-50 range.
Let’s not, these constant lists and crap have ruined this sub.
Fringe top 30 for me. I have him #31.
Yeah seems about right.
Top 10,000 for sure
Top 20 could be possible, but top 30 at the bare minimum.
Champions win rings
Robert Horry greater champion than MJ.. Russ is the King Daddy topper… case closed
I feel like we’re at the point where people have forgotten how ridiculous Harden was in his prime, he’s not top 10 but the responses in this thread are disrespectful.
He’s nowhere near top 10 and anyone even insinuating it should be ridiculed. We need to stop over glorifying people and players. He is top 50. He’s closer to 50 than 10. It’s disrespectful to the history of the league and the players that came before him to say hes close to top 10.
We don’t need to constantly lie and hyperbolize players achievements to make them seem greater than they are. He’s top 50⁄40 at best
Never won a title, never even took a team to the Finals. Top 10 is absurd. It’s not direspectful to Harden, a first ballot Hall of Famer, to say that.
He was very close just ran into the warriors dynasty. You think sga is better because he won a title?
It takes a team and luck to win a tittle. No one on the Knicks is close to Hardens level but they won last year. The title argument is absurd
His Rockets almost beat arguably the greatest team of all time. If he’d just had a bit of luck, he would have beat them. And then probably would have a championship.
Also, he did make a finals as an important contributor, just not as the main guy. Still worth mentioning.
I know sports can’t be reduced to “what if” - we have to look at what actually happened. But I think it’s fair to say that what happened in his career was still extremely great, and it’s valid to acknowledge that this guy only missed being a champion by a razor-thin margin.
Talent wise he may be up there. You cannot find 10 guys more skilled. Him just disappointing in the playoffs is what kills whatever case he had
rings argument is so incredibly stupid in a team game like basketball. at his peak, harden was better than anyone else playing in the league. because his teams didnt win a championship during those three seasons doesnt mean he wasnt as good as lesser players who were on teams who did
He literally took OKC to the finals….
Flair Checks out. He’s definitely top 30
Dude ran into possibly the greatest team in NBA history. He just so happened to be in his prime during their dominance and in the same conference. As far as his production on the court, it was top tier level. Few players in NBA history could do what he could.
And his #2 got injured when they were ahead in the series against GS. People fail to understand that a lot of these championship runs don’t happen without a little luck on their side.
Best offensive player of his generation. One of the best offensive players in history. I don’t think he is top ten but to say he is easily closer to 50 than 10 is disrespectful to the league. Very revisionist of his game and how he changed the game of basketball. His offensive playstyle changed guard play across the NBA because of how unstoppable it was.
Averaging 36ppg across an entire season? Thats among the best offensive seasons of all time.
He’s top 10 all time at disappearing in the playoffs.
Curry better, tremendous value without the ball, more efficient. Harden’s net rating in 2018 was worse without CP3 than vice versa, and their combined net rating was uninspiring. It’s a problem with him being so ball dominant, awkward fit with most stars
Cap. Harden can never be the best offensive player of any generation that includes LeBron, curry and KD
Harden is arguably a top 10 scorer and top 10 offensive player.
The line between Harden and some of the genuine top 10 guys is not that big.
He’s not arguably a top 10 in the things you mentioned?? He’s easily top 10 in both of those and I’d say arguably top 5 on those
He’s nowhere near top 10 and anyone even insinuating it should be ridiculed.
They’re calling it the most reddit comment of all time
He’s somewhere in the 30-35ish range all-time. If he had won a title then he’d move up a good 15 spots, but he still wouldn’t be even close to the top 10 discussion.
A reason i find ring culture silly, is that if KD gets injured during the 2018 postseason instead of the 2019. Harden gains “15 spots” in the GOAT rankings while being the same dude
And there’s nothing wrong with that. He put together a few insane years but not long enough to be a top ten player. He’s top 50 all time and that’s an insane accomplishment.
Nah he’s top 25 at least.
nope
a top 10 player needs to have a defensive anything imo
Magic Johnson was a below average defender for most of his career
Could say he’s had a top tier 10 season of all time
He is closer to 10 than 50. He should be ahead of Barkley
100
What’s disrespectful is being just above .500 record in the playoffs
Calling him top-10 is actually disrespectful to him. It’s so far from the truth that it’s obvious he’s just saying it. There are 10 active players today alone that have had better careers than him.
a top 10 offensive like 3-5 year prime doesn’t get you top 10 overall, especially when you don’t win anything but a singular regular season award
I’m as a big a Harden fan as they come, buts generous to put him in top 20s. He’s more like top 30 if I’m being real.
Coaches talk about all time accolades when they are going to cut the minutes of their aging star. No coach talks about all time greatness when the guy is great right now.
I’d say he’s a top 5 SG all time for sure.
He has an argument for 3rd but is probably 4th.
Wade’s peak was better. It’s why I would take him over Harden but then Wade also played for a better coached/run franchise in the Heat.
Also was a much better two-way player.
Hardens peak was MVP and 5 top 2 finishes in mvp voting.
Emphasis on the shooting guard aspect I will argue with people nonstop that he never truly elevated his teammates
Downvotes require a citation btw. Prove he isn’t a selfish player
He led the league in assists. How is that a selfish player?
What teammates did he elevate truly. Kd won mvp with russ and PG had an MVP esque season with him. You can say he’s more talented individually but he literally never elevated teammates
Well you can always skip the he “he is all time top part” :)
He’s top 50 for sure, but lack of team accomplishments kinda hurts him. I know he was one game away from beating the GSW but his team played better without him the Clippers series, it’s a hard to definitively give a spot in the top 30 or 40 but in the 50s I don’t think we’ve ever seen a scorer and passer like him in a while.
Top 10 (scorer)
TOP 20 IG?
I mean, his coach doesn’t have to rank him all time haha. Just say, “I mean he’s an all time great. Going to the Hall of Fame. He continues to be what he’s always been, an elite basketball player.”
He could have just kept it generic and said “hall of famer” or “all time great” or “member of the 75th anniversary all time team”
His current coach could simply not talk unprompted about where he sits all-time. Most coaches don’t!
He might be a top 10 scorer
Not that?
Yeah simply “this guy is a HoF’er” would suffice
Why? Harden had a great game and everyone knows he’s just boosting his guy. Who cares? Harden is a legit hall of famer. No one thinks he’s top ten but it’s not like Atkinson was saying this about a bench player.
Because its a lie?
if you’re not a social media addict you probably don’t know the consensus top ten list by heart
MJ, Russell, Kareem, Duncan, LeBron, Steph, Magic, Bird, Shaq…Harden?
Top 10 regular season maybe
Top 10 regular season offense maybe
Top 10, regular season, offense, with the ball.
Y’all are hating. Harden is definitely one of the Top 10 regular season offensive players of all time in 2018
Because of foul baiting. He probably doesn’t get that same level even now. Def not in other eras when they wouldn’t have called all that nonsense.
Show me a scoring title and I’ll show you a huge fta figure
Luka is pretty good in today’s game. Harden was better at just about everything than Luka.
Top 10 guard maybe
9th in all time scoring all time. I think Kenny just didn’t state it correct.
Yeah, he’s literally top 10 all-time in scoring. Kenny didn’t say what top 10 he was referring to. But Harden is famously on an important top 10 list.
Yep, dude has consistently been absolute ass in the playoffs when it matters most. Im sure someone will bring up the 2-3 games he did well in the post season, but dude is the absolute definition of a star player with a completely absent clutch gene
He played 85 playoff games in Houston which was his prime and he averaged 28/6/7 in those games. You’re talking about him way too harshly. His elimination game stats are pretty much identical and were at 59% TS which was great for that era
And like, he has overtime takeover games where he solod the KD Warriors to avoid going down 3-1 and tie the series. That’s a huge game even if it isnt an elimination game, as was the game 3 to avoid going down 3-0.
You’re just hating
Lmao. He literally holds records for ineptitude in the playoffs.
In roughly 25% (46games) of his playoff career, he has had as many or more turnovers than made field goals.
Nearly a quarter of his career playoff games feature him shooting under 25% or finishing with fewer than 3-4 made field goals
He is a perrenial choker and the sample size is massive. You cant win a chip when your star player chokes 2 games every series on avg.
explain something to me
when did anyone EVER give a fuck about “more turnovers than made field goals” lmao. NICK WRIGHT said this shit and all you weirdos ran with it
Think about it. If the guy has two threes and two freethrows for 8 points, that stat would value 6 pts on 3 layups more because its more “made field goals”
As for how many games he has with less than 5fgs or whatever - the guy has 195 playoff games, and only 85 of them were in Houston. Before Houston he came off the bench and averaged, what, 10FGA a game? So 4FGM is 40%? Hardly worth crying about for 18 years. And since he left Houston hes become an aging pass first guard.
The guy has NEVER missed the playoffs in any stage of his career. Of course he has a lot of those volume type stats.
How many real chances to players have to win a ring on the non-dynasty teams? 1 or 2? Giannis had 1. Jokic had 1. SGA so far has had 1. Brunson has had 1. Etc.
Harden had 2018 and 2021. Both of those teams lost because of INJURY. Nothing else.
He hasn’t had his entire prime be lined up with a stacked ass, 100m over the tax roster. Those teams before 2018 were NOT title teams and they got further than they were meant to go because of him.
He has anti clutch. Idk what that is, but it’s what he has.
The word is “choker”.
Check our playoff EPM casual
What was it in game 7s?
Victimized by the craziest shooting drought of all time by his role player teammates against the greatest team of all time and this is the narrative casuals run with. Who has it worse than us Harden truthers
you because Harden shot like absolute shit in the games they DID win. He wasn’t responsible for those
Role players couldn’t carry the MVP this time around
It wasn’t crazy. They had dead legs which affects jump shots especially 3 pointers and the reason they kept settling for those 3 pointers was because they had dead legs. They ran out of gas. I would count that playoff run for Harden the same as Dirk’s and Wade’s solo rings though. Neither of those guys would have beaten that Warriors team either. Lebron would have won with that Houston team though. But he’s also much better than Harden especially in the playoffs, but people aren’t making that comparison in this thread.
Imagine how different these discussions would be if the Rockets were actually able to beat the KD-Warriors and Cavs that year.
Compare the fanfare of Giannis vs Harden. If Harden beats that GSW team, and the Bucks don’t win that championship, their entire legacies are swapped.
Giannis is a perennial choker, and Harden is a top 20 player of all time.
CP3 was injured that run, but if the Rockets win he probably still gets a chip to his name, and jumps several spots in that all time ranking too.
Sure. Also need to swap their defense too. As in one of them stop playing defense, and harden becomes dpoy.
LOL yeah dude imagine Jordan wins 0 championship his legacy would be so different
Jordan’s Bulls didn’t go against a 73-9 team that added Kevin Durant the following season and then lose their second best player in that series up 3-2. It’s a fair conversation to be having.
Really trying to put harden in conversation with dpoys here? Jesus.
Forget the rings for a second, and just think about defense.
When did Harden win a DPOY?
When he had the “James Harden defensive juggernaut” compilation made for his highlights on that end of the court
Not many top 20 guys have a DPOY
He still wouldn’t be a consensus top 10 player.
not top 10 but his coach calling him top 10 wouldn’t sound as insane lol
He’d be in the 10-15 tier
Maybe he should’ve made some more threes in game 7
So stupid to cause that wouldn’t change him as a player if he won and put in same performances he isn’t better he just won
Steph is a fringe top 10 player depending on who you ask. Harden is nowhere near close.
Harden is top 10 in all-time scoring. Maybe that’s what Kenny was referring to?
Steph is top ten.
Depending on who you ask, like he said.
I love Steph but the 1 FMVP to show for 4 rings along with not a single all defensive team selection really hurts him.
Other than magic, Steph would be the only potential top 10 player who had no defensive accolades to show for it.
Ik someone will say that accolades shouldn’t matter so much, impact on the game blah blah, but when it comes to the top 10, yeah it matters.
Any other top 10 candidate has multiple FMVP and/or multiple all defensive selections. Obv bill Russell and wilt were vets by the time those existed tho.
1 fmvp are we back to acting like he wasnt ROBBED in 2015?
Offense is greater than defense in the NBA. A great offensive player is always more valuable and Steph is one of the greatest ever there. His offense is so good that it outweighs most defensive deficiencies. I wouldn’t put him above the best 2 way players who were great on both sides, but he’s above most other players.
Problem is that plenty of the top 10 players have comparable at least offense while also having great defense.
That’s the issue like I said. Everythinatters when it comes to top 10.
Steph offense does not negate the combined offense and defense of a lebron, a Shaq, an MJ, a bird, a Duncan, etc.
Offense is better than defense sounds nice and rolls off the tongue, but your final sentence is all that matters. When discussing the top 10 younare largely discussing many if the best two way players who Steph simply doesn’t stack up against.
Still not above Magic in my eyes. People forget Magic won 5 MVPs and 3 FMVPs with guys like Bird and MJ running around. GOAT PG till this day!
Well I mean he should clearly have one more FMVP that’s just kinda ridiculous to hold against him.
People do have a tendency to act like Steph was somehow much better than KD when in reality KD made the team invincible Steph wouldn’t have been able to do what he did without pretty much like the second best player in the world on his team.
Steph has won pre KD and post KD with the same team.
In fact, Steph has proven to carry a whole team on his own while KD just hops around when things aren’t in his favour
What has KD done without Steph since? A whole lot of nothing.
Yeah, Steph is amazing, but there are at least 10 other guys who have a better resume than him.
He has a case, but I wouldn’t put him on my top 10.
Then again, the whole “top 10” debate is a little silly, and we should just value players for what they are and appreciate their greatness. It’s a team game, and comparing individual players once you get to a certain level is quite difficult.
Accolades definitely matter, but there aren’t always accolades that exist for things people do to contribute. Consider that there’s a ‘scoring title’, but there’s no ‘VORP title’ or anything like that.
No, not depending on who you ask lol.
Steph Curry is a top 10 all time player. He altered the entire league with his play. It’s not a debate.
Signed, Warriors hater
He’s not a consensus top 10 player. Lebron, MJ, KAJ, Bird & Magic, Duncan, Bill Russell, and then it depend how you want to rank Kobe, Shaq and Wilt. Putting Steph over any of them is fine but it’s not a clear cut.
Also Magic has 5 MVPs and 3 FMVPs to show for it, that’s colossal.
Steph is a tough one because do you value winning more like how Magic did or do you value changing the whole entire league? IMO Steph is better than Magic but I didn’t grow up watching Magic but I watched Steph fuck up entire franchises dreams.
Magic and Bird saved the entire league. This is why I don’t put too many players above those two very often.
Idk if saving the league should really be used as part of the measurement of how great a player was. Should really be talking about their basketball skill when determining who’s the best.
It’s not like those 2 guys didn’t win multiple MVPs and championships along with saving the league. I also bring it up because one of the main reasons people give for Steph is that he changed the way basketball is played. While being true, it’s a similar accomplishment to “saving the league”.
When discussing all time, Steph and Magic are in the same boat, not opposites.
He’s better than Magic and I’m avowed hater of that mouth guard chewing front runner. He pouts like a baby when things aren’t going his way. Problem is (for me as a hater anyway) that things go his way far too often for me to say that he’s not one of the best players of all time. His final title proved he belongs in the top 10. Magic had a great team every single year he was in the league and gets inflated because of that.
Better than Magic? So curry is a top 4 player? Because I can’t imagine someone putting Magic in the second half of their top 10.
I can very easily
Honestly, I am open to Magic over Steph, but as I said, I watched Steph in high school, and I will always remember the 50-point game in MSG. Watching highlights of Magic doesn’t hit the same as watching Steph highlights.
There maybe some bias then cause you watched Steph play and not magic and that’s completely fine. I have the same case with other players in same scenarios.
This is ironic because Harden’s team (Houston) did more to change NBA 3pt culture than Steph ever did. Steph is the one who benefitted from the changes, he didn’t have anything to do with creating them. If Houston and others hadn’t started focusing on analytics and shooting threes like crazy, Steph would still be a fringe all-star averaging 4.7 threes a game like he was until 25yo.
At their peaks, it can be argued Harden was the better player at times. I would not call it “nowhere near close.”
agreed. Harden arguably had the. better prime. Steph only had the better peak, longevity, accolades, consistency, and impact to put him above harden. If you put all of that aside, then yea the gap is much smaller.
Steph also was fortunate to be surrounded by better talent in his prime. And I genuinely don’t understand how you’re putting longevity for Steph above Harden. Harden’s one of the most durable guys in the league and rarely misses games unlike Steph.
Atkinson just says wild shit from time to time 😭
He’s right , Harden is 9th all time in points . In the interview he starts off by stating harden has more 50pt games than Kobe. Then later compares him to Steph , wild but the whole interview does a better job at saying hey let’s appreciate one of the greatest scorers we’ve ever seen.
I mean, the guy has chucked up 10,000 3-pointers despite shooting 36%. And is #3 all-time in FTM. Of course hes got a lot of points. Have we already forgotten how much of a flopper he was, just because SGA has perfected the art?
This is stupid lol. 36% in threes is efficient offense. It’s equal to 56% shooting twos, 1.08 points per shot.
This is good offense especially back in his prime days where offense were a little worse. Plus he can get this on demand through stepbacks, when alot of the 40 percenters needs to be setup/helped first
I said it was why he has a lot of points, not that it was stupid. Though not many players would have a green light like that without shooting at a higher percentage.
He’s the Carmelo of this era. A great scorer. But I don’t think we should forget how unwatchable he made the game with his flopping.
Harden’s top 10 on the scoring list, probably what he’s referring to, but he wasn’t direct which leaves room for misinterpretation
https://www.basketball-reference.com/leaders/pts_career.html
Lol top 10 strip club attendees
But think of the girls he put through school
Top 2
Patrons*
Analytically he’s right
Actually though. Harden’s EPM playoffs included is top 10 I think lmao
Almost forgot the reference for a moment 😅
Jordan, Wilt, Harden has the top 3 greatest season statistically
No, not statistically, analytically
Top 10 scorer - no easy feat.
Top what?
There are 12 players that Durant can’t pass up and Harden falls a full tier below Durant
If you only saw Harden’s lowlights you’d wonder why anyone respects him at all. If you only saw Harden’s highlights you’d wonder why anyone disrespects him at all. Such a confounding player and career
The coach is obviously going to pump up his guy, especially after a crazy ass 51-point game, but of course he’s not Top 10 of all time
HOFer absolutely, but too 10 no chance
Top 10 all time is crazy.
Well yeah if u put harden in the 1980s he’d be top 1 rn
Top 10 guy on the Cavs roster this year maybe.
At the strip club….. definitely
Maybe top 100
He’s talking about Hardin scoring a lot of points, where Hardin sits at #10 now all time on the NBA/ABA leaderboard. People really are wildly over sensitive getting so upset at a head coach appreciating their player scoring a bunch of points lol.
I think there’s absolutely an argument for Harden as a Top 10 scorer of all time, which is likely what Kenny is getting at here.
Obviously he lacks the resume otherwise to justify Top 10 in general but it’s hard to think of too many folks better than him at putting the ball in the hoop
I think there’s absolutely an argument for Harden as a Top 10 scorer of all time,
I mean there’s no argument, he literally is a top 10 scorer of all time, he’s 9th right now.
That’s what Kenny was referring to.
The argument is him shooting 42⁄33 splits in the playoffs. When defenses stiffen up and refs aren’t giving him bullshit calls, he can’t score for shit except on volume.
If he was at 45⁄33 in the playoffs, would that make him a great player?
No, he’s not a great playoff performer either.
Came here to say this. He’s also top ten in per game I believe, isn’t he? Which is even better
KobeBronKDMJLukaJerry WestLarry BirdStephWiltKareem
I definitely wouldn’t say there’s no argument. There’s 10 guys right there you can argue are a better scorer than Harden especially when you include ability to get a bucket in regular season and playoffs
Luka is currently not a better scorer all time than Harden. He could be, but he’s a long ways away.
Steph, Bird, and West aren’t either.
Bird and West are frankly absurd suggestions, honestly.
lol in what world is curry not a better scorer
Maybe higher
Giannis called Luka maybe the greatest offensive player/scorer ever (I don’t think he is tho, but he has an argument the way he’s going) but functionally, what’s the difference between Luka and prime Harden? They’re basically the same player
Maybe in the regular season. There’s like 4 0 guys you’d rather have scoring in the playoffs
I think there’s an argument for top 3
“Analytically” top 10 all-time, he means
This guy loves saying stupid cheesy nonsense
He never specified
Analytically?!
Wow finally someone agrees with me, thanks Kenny.
He’s for sure a top ten nba player in changing the landscape of basketball. Go to any basketball court and watch how the youth play- 1 on 1 in their bag with a step back at the ready. Thats all harden
You gotta hype up your boy
All-time top 10 in $ spent at strip clubs.