[Highlight] Rudy Gobert offensive rebound + Ayo Dosunmu wide open catch-and-shoot 3 called off because the referee wanted to see if the previous shot had hit the rim
Moderator Announcement
Read More »
Replays/alternate angles
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Critical situation that you can let play out and review after? Nah blow it dead. Fucking a
That’s the part that kills me. Why are you blowing a whistle in crunch time of a one possession game to check something that you can check after the possession has ended? How can you justify that?
The NFL had this problem on fumbles and more or less has eliminated the issue despite some kinks
If anything in an NBA game where there’s so many more impactful plays this should be easier to do
It’s insane for a sport like basketball to be clearly refereed worse than the NFL when being an NFL ref is like 100x harder.
Is it harder? I mean, yeah there’s a lot more going on and it’s way more chaotic, but I think the NBA balances that out with basically having to be reffing for the entire game. NFL refs have plenty of down time between plays to get set up and prepped for the next one, which I have to imagine helps a lot.
You think they could just go and do the review of this after the shot not before. Let the play go, if he hits the shot review it after and if it ends up being dead with no advantage call the review then.
they should implement continuation for these plays after their review. ain’t the player’s fault that refs are interrupting a live play
The problem is you could argue that the Knicks stopped playing and could have contested the shot. He should have just not blown the fucking whistle
There wasn’t a knicks player within 15 feet of him when he was going up for the shot and the whistle blew
In crunchtime they try to get the clock right instantly just because it can really change strategies. But in that instance where Minnesota easily grabs the rebound you gotta let it play out.
… Because you literally can’t do that
NBA refs review things all the time. Do you truly believe there is any material difference between checking to see if a player got the shot off before the shot clock expired or whether the ball hit the rim?
What are you even saying?
They can’t let a play continue and then go back and review if it was a shot clock in this situation. You can only do that on a made basket to see if they got it off in time and they would have called for a stoppage right away to check it because the score obviously matters in the last minutes of a game.
In every sport with review, its better to keep it live and fix it after than it is to blow it dead, then fix it
I genuinely don’t think the NBA cares about watchability. To Adam Silver every dead ball is an opportunity to cram in another fanduel ad. I’ve stopped watching most games live just so I can skip past the constant stoppages of play and ticky-tacky defensive fouls
Same, the game flow is in a bad place.
I swear FTs didn’t take so long when I was younger. From a foul being called to the 2nd of two getting shot and the ball being back in play is like 50-70 seconds. How do they drag it out so much? Drives me crazy
Baseball has better pace of play than basketball nowadays. It’s crazy
The wolves had to challenge a clear flop by KAT. There were so many bad calls in the fourth quarter.
Was not a clear flop lol
He pulled his head back from nearly getting hit with an elbow and then stumbled from lower body contact by gobert. Overturn was correct but calling a flop there was nonsense. Ref just mad he made a bad call.
I don’t know if there’s ever been a clearer flop. He didn’t stumble because of lower body contact. He stumbled because he was exaggerating the head movement so much he threw himself off balance. It’s one thing to flinch from an elbow, its another to pull your head back and never attempt to straitened it and continue your backward rotation well after the elbow has cleared to throw yourself off balance
Are you sure about that? This angle makes it pretty clear that the knee affected his balance. Never been a clearer flop is insane.
from nearly getting hit with an elbow
It was like 6 inches away, stop the cope.
Was less than that that but it’s besides the point. The only cope is the false narrative Kat was trying to sell to get a call or act like it hit him - he didn’t. He reacted to it swinging in front of his face and then had his knee slammed into.
Stop watching super slow mo replays and watch the actual play
Yeah terrible all around
The Knicks had to challenge a clear charge on Lamelo when he barreled into Josh Hart with his feet planted. Bad calls went both ways.
just a reminder how fixed these games are. maybe not all but DOH! ED MALLOY!
It sucks this happened, but I don’t think there’s an easy alternative here.
What does “let it play out” mean? Say the shot misses and the Knicks go on a fast break. Do you stop them? If you don’t stop them and let them score the fast break, then you not only force them to play an extra possession of defense, you remove their points if the shot clock had expired. What if there’s a flagrant-2 or a technical foul on the resulting play? Does it no longer count since the shot clock expired previously?
You also can’t just go by whether or not the clock was reset, because then we’re just letting the hometown clock operator (not an NBA referee) be the sole judge of whether or not the ball hit the rim.
It seems like the approach the NBA takes is that the ref stops live play, but only if s/he feels the shot was an airball and the time would have expired. I didn’t watch the game and don’t have a horse in this race, but my suspicion is this is exactly what happened. The ref for whatever reason thought the ball didn’t hit the rim and he blew the whistle roughly when the clock would have expired. We can be mad at the ref for not seeing the ball hit the rim, but I don’t know of a better solution for stopping play. It’s the equivalent of missing a goaltend or a foul, not a great reflection on the ref, but not necessarily a bad rule or policy.
I appreciate your argument even though I disagree with it. The ref who blew the whistle was across the court from the shot at the rim. The arc of the ball toward the rim ends when it goes straight down after the shot, a clear indication that it did in fact hit the rim.
The easiest way is waiting for a stop in play. For all of your scenarios, I think my answer would be that the refs let it go because it did not turn out to impact the flow of the game. How much shit gets missed and it’s fine because how play continued wasn’t fundamentally altered?
The problem with what happened in this situation is that the refs themselves disrupted the flow of play on a very unlikely what if that turned out to be wrong. They did not allow the flow of the game to continue and then fix things, they disrupted the flow and thereby fundamentally altered the outcome. That’s not their role. It’s a hand on the scale.
Obviously I’m biased because I’m rooting for the wolves but it absolutely sucks that now this game has to be a ref fuck-up game instead of a close game between two strong teams where the Knicks held off our valiant second half comeback. As a fan, that’s the game I want, even when my team loses. I don’t want ref meddling to be the story. That’s just my two cents.
Flip it the other way. What if the clock operator didn’t reset the clock and the buzzer sounded, it would still be a stoppage in play, the basket wouldn’t count and it would be side out Wolves after review. Everyone would lament the bad clock operator but not change the system.
I feel the same way here. If the ref genuinely thinks the shot missed he should stop play as if it did. The ambiguity here is whether or not he blew the whistle because he was sure it missed or because he wasn’t sure. If he wasn’t sure then I agree he shouldn’t stop play (don’t call what you didn’t see).
Edit: https://www.reddit.com/r/nba/s/Ev3oEWtVyc this is the rule apparently, ref should stop play if they’re not sure at the next pause in action, but “pause in action” is not defined. Sigh.
There’s a lot of sense to this argument. basically, we shouldn’t entrust shot clock operators with critical rules like this, refs are the stewards of the rules and highly trained professionals, they should make the final call on the shot clock
I think what needs to change then is the messaging behind it. De Rosa needs to own his call and state that he is stopping the game due to a shot clock violation that he is calling, then they can review the call that he made.
it wouldn’t have changed the unfortunate outcome but it would have felt a bit less slimey
Yeah I’m honestly considering just being done with this league. Watching these refs all year call our team completely differently because guys don’t flop has made watching games more annoying than entertaining. Tonight pissed me off more than any game I’ve seen in a long time.
i only watch the playoffs these days. regular season games are nice to have on in the background but zzzzzzzz soooo many stoppages & ads & weird ass calls/no calls that seem to always tiptoe the betting lines. like nahhhh
How would that work? When do they stop and review it? What if the next stoppage is in a minute. Do you then roll back one minute of play?
Well you treat every possession as its own individual moment. And you remove that one moment
Look up the official rule and come back here
Share with the class
There’s a whole team of refs in NJ that can review while the game is ongoing. They do this for 3s all the time. They’ll go back and make it a 2 or a 3.
Would honestly make the game more interesting: did that last play really count? Tune in next time on dragonball z.
Deplorable
You literally can’t do that lol
You can’t let it play out and then review it after. Was unfortunate for the wolves but understandable live it looked like an air ball and shot clock violation
It did not. And the whistle came from the ref furthest from the play. C’mon man
It’s possible it’s that ref’s job to keep track of the clock. The baseline ref can’t do it easily, so it’s between the two sideline refs, and the far ref probably has the best angle to watch both the play and the clock.
It did not what? Not even sure what you’re saying.
It did not look like an airball. Apologies if that didn’t seem to follow
It did not look like it missed rim
Why not? Wolves had imminent possession. So if you look at it after you can wave off the basket and give the Knicks the ball. It’s not like the Knicks had a fast break opportunity before the shot clock expired
What happens if wolves miss the shot and the Knicks get out in transition? You blow it dead there and take away their advantage? Or go back and see it actually was an air ball and adjust the clock?
Or wolves miss but get another offensive rebound but we can’t blow it dead until they finally score or a stoppage or play?
Could go on forever with that logic
Ok but then if knicks get a runaway 2 you’d want the violation… fwiw
Dumb pointless comment.
I mean it’s true. The whistle changes things for everybody, that’s why the best decision is to let it ride and review after the possession.
It’s tough because what if the Wolves miss and get another OREB. You can’t go that far back.
But if we get a back and forth… atp do you just negate and go back to this
that you can let play out and review after
You can’t to be fair.
The fact that all the players around the rim keep playing is all you need to know.
If the ball never touches the rim, all the Knicks would be screaming for a shot clock violation.
Also, how arrogant do you have to be to stop the play when you’re the furthest ref from the ball/rim while all other refs saw it hit the rim. Absolutely bonkers.
ego had to have been big if he was butthurt enough to give finch a tech for telling him he’s not the star of the show
The ref was a clown throughout the game tbh
Precisely. They whine about everything, they definitely would have there.
Investigate that ref
They weren’t going to let Wolves win after Finch said they weren’t here to watch them.
I don’t think coach was even mad one way or the other! Refs were on bullshit both ways all through the first quarter
I don’t think I have ever been so offended by bad reffing as a neutral who didn’t even watch the game. This is atrocious lol
“oh yea coach!? well watch me … screw you out of a three!!”
Hopefully the game didn’t end 102-99, and this waived off wide open three didn’t affect the outcome!
Hopefully Ayo didn’t have an over/under of 2.5 3pm!
Hopefully the wolves weren’t +1.5
This would have been a highly contested 3 of the whistle wasn’t blown
It’s like that one ref that got to ref the Sixers-Celtics playoff game years ago who turned out to be a massive Celtics fan and would post on a burner defending himself lol
Jersey native
you actually made me look it up lol. Kentucky born (thankfully?)
The refs were just bad tonight, for both sides.
The league nowadays will find ties to gambling and give him a raise
Insane. We tied the game with all of the momentum…and the refs miscalled and ended the game
Any time the Wolves did something positive the refs called something it was truly abysmal all night
genuinely baffling man
I originally thought they blew the whistle because OG kicked the ball. But that was an awful, awful call by the ref who had no business doing that from so far away.
Same here I was wondering wtf they were whistling for, that is genuinely baffling
Ref had money on this one
Let’s see… my 2 closest officials aren’t calling shot clock violation, none of the players are complaining about shot clock violation, Minnesota has possession for a wide open 3…
YEA LEMME GET IN THERE AND MAKE IT ABOUT ME
As a Wolves fan…im almost numb to it now. I watch the NBA every night and I see calls like this once in a while but I see weird stuff that is just baffling in almost every Wolves game.
And i get it, its my fav team..every fan thinks this…but i promise you. Watch wolves games on a consistent basis and you will change your mind. Idk what we did, but its always a a complete mind ____. The fact im used to it scares the hell out of me.
You guys do have a lot of late game shenanigans on Reddit for the last 5 years. Like a lot more than any other team where it never benefits you guys ever.
Havent been that pissed off leaving TC in a loooooong time. What a terrible product
Completely numb. Just another game where the refs screw over the wolves. Almost expect it.
We have to be far enough ahead where the refs cant take it away from us.
this. unfortunately, in marginally close games where both teams are pretty sloppy, it makes it easier for the refs to land their sweet bets
It’s because we aren’t a large market team
I see your Wolves and raise you a Sixers
That’s what y’all get
The ball VERY CLEARLY hits the rim. Absolutely no need to stop the play to review it. This is a fireable offense for JB DeRosa. Should be demoted to G League games for the rest of the season or suspended at a minimum.
Problem is the far side ref called it. Not the ref on the side of the basket that had a clear view.
The ref calling it from the furthest position is the problem. Thats not really his call. He has the worst vantage point. If the other refs don’t call it and they are right there then theres a reason lol
It is his call. You are absolutely wrong. Trail has control of the shot clock. The lead and the center official are watching the play in the key and off ball. The trail has shot clock responsibilities - this is the case from high school all the way to the pros. The justification is that you have a wide angle view of both the shot clock and above the rim play. If you’re the lead official on the baseline, you’re looking at post matchups and box out for fouls and have a terrible angle at the rim. You shouldn’t be looking up if you have two or three matchups in your PCA.
The real issue is in regards to whether or not you stop play to check that. With such a tight play and a game on the line, you better be damn sure that you have a good reason to stop action with time running down in the fourth. Your job as an official isn’t to interfere when things are tight there.
But yeah, if people are going to shit on the officials, at least know the responsibilities of the different positions. Otherwise you just look like a moron.
Well the refs pants being that tight also made him look like a moron.
Technically all 3 refs are watching a different thing, so maybe his job was watching the basket there. But you gotta just default to your partner there and let it ride. Terrible vantage point to try to call that.
I get why he did it, but he’s doing it from the worst view on the floor.
They all watch for multiple things, but even still… The tv angle on the replay was close to his own’s, pretty damn obvious. But, the thing is he could’ve just let the play go through and check it immediately after the play had stopped, no point in stopping play there
Even worse. Stay in your lane.
Which makes you wonder why he even blew the whistle. Does he not trust his colleagues competency? This call was a bummer but GGs
All the refs are watching a different thing, so it’s possible he’s the one watching the shot.
But you gotta rely on your partner there. Terrible angle to try to call that.
You’re all over this thread simping for the refs it’s embarrassing
Bro that was not clear at all. Calling it in the middle of the play was definitely dumb as shit though.
This would all be solved if the knicks could make a damn shot in the 4th
to be fair, your defense was excellent. Gobert on KAT and Kuminga on Brunson had everything under clamps. This game was definitely going into OT with Ayo’s 3 pointer
man I wish it went to OT, best matchup of the night
Bad calls would be easier to accept if gambling wasn’t such a huge issue.
Boom. David Stern would have never allowed this. Silver ruined the league.
man david stern let a ref who clearly cheated games for money stay on
Investigated by the FBI no less
Okay, but he would not have allowed an nba partnership with sports betting. I think that’s much worse. And there is a ref who was betting on games in the G league trying to work his way back to regular games.
i really dont see how keeping a ref who clearly cheated for money is less bad than an ad sponsorship but whatever. its a dumb narrative to pretend stern was any better
You don’t understand how capitalism and incentives work, then.None of these people have actual principles.
I actually don’t know if I agree with this. Long before nba partnered with gambling sites, people would claim the games were rigged.
People have always raged about bad calls.
After the Tatum tech yesterday for throwing the ball where the ref pointed, and the refs today after Finch said “nobody came to watch you” to having four non-calls on the Wolves that would’ve given them free throws…hard to believe there isn’t some insider trading or something going on that jeopardizes the integrity of the game.
Man, like, I was laughing at the Lakers’ technicals yesterday, especially the one for Reaves saying “You’re always too slow!” after an 8-second violation. The refs were all over the place for both teams and clearly couldn’t handle the game or the players. Not to mention the ref having beef with Luka after he said, “That’s nowhere close to a tech,” and the ref looked like he wanted to fight him :D
But for real! Tatum is on some parental guidance for 10 year olds kind of stuff. I swear he’ll start getting technicals just for looking in the direction of the refs.
Whatever happend to LA is one thing but Boston and Tatum is some crazy stuff….
I’m a Celtics fan so definitely biased but feels like Tatum has one of the shortest leashes for a tech I’ve seen in the nba. Idk what it is or why thats the case
While Luka has the absolute longest. I don’t understand
Its super annoying
Honestly no one knows, whether fans or not… Tatum can be a lot of things but he is not known for a being a bad mannered dude.
it definitely feels like at least once or twice a season I see a tatum tech for something that just makes me go ??
NBa needs to investigate the refs.Some of their antics scream game fixing.
all of that can be explained by refs being proud and resentful, no need to jump to fixing games
Tbf picking a fight with the refs is just dumb. I understand the frustration but if you’re gonna go after refs that particular way you can’t expect it to end well
This is not an ethical or moral statement - in theory they should be more professional - but the reality of human nature + subjective nature of most calls is not going to end well
The check cleared.
That was a wild call.
Incredible. Let them play ball and check. Or get your fucking eyes checked. We were robbed.
Not with 1:40 left in the game you weren’t. Plenty of time to tie it up again. Reggie Miller scored 8 points in 9 seconds to beat the Knicks in the 90s.
Robbed doesn’t always mean robbed of a win, I meant we were robbed of 3 critical points. Your team made 3 FGs the whole quarter. 102-102 like it should’ve been gives the Wolves a significant opportunity to win that one.
That’s valid, I thought you were saying robbed of a win. Either way, officiating was incredibly poor tonight.
Right. Literally in the Wolves previous game they won due to an INC with 8 seconds to go where they got a steal and a free layup and won a 1 point game.
The Wolves would not have needed the steal if the refs didn’t miss a foul on Lamelo 20 seconds earlier.
https://official.nba.com/l2m/L2MReport.html?gameId=0022600254
And Lamelo had an uncalled carry. we can go on and on. Stop whining about a single play call if you don’t want other teams to come at you with the same whining
Don’t they have shit where they take away points afterwards because of the review center lol what’s the point in stopping the play there
Total momentum killer right here dude
Just let the possesion play out and then review the call , but the ball did hit the rim
This should really be embarrassing for the NBA.
I get why they did it because the shot clock was at 2 seconds, but you just have to let that possession play out and review after. That’s such a bad decision to whistle there.
Insane
NBA refs suck so much this season. Games taking longer with the challenges and so many stupid pointless mistakes that can be avoided like this.
What’s annoying is that coaches have to challenge really obvious calls. Or they miss things and after the game address that they missed something.
Yeah, especially if it’s like a clear out of bounds missed call in the first quarter, even if you win you still basically have to commit to not challenging anything the rest of the game in case you need the second one in crunch time
Mmhmm. I remember last season Mitch Johnson crashed out and got a tech because the call was wrong, challenged it, won the challenge but lost the time out, still had a tech. I think he said in the post game presser it was frustrating that he was right all along and they only saw it after he forced the extra review.
Ref should be fired. This is sheer incompetence and there’s no room for this bs in the NBA
If he was betting it should be prison.
To hold me?
That ref needs to be fired
i see this stuff & see the partnership with Kalshi the NBA has & it all makes sense. fuck this sport & the enshittification of gambling
I fucking hate sports now and it was my greatest love.
Fuck shareholders, fuck private equity, fuck gambling, and fuck everyone. I hate everything, nothing is fun. Capitalism has robbed me of the only thing I hold sacred. I hate you all and I hate myself. Fuck. This.
The ref who blows the whistle isn’t even close to it.
Refs never made mistakes prior to legalized gambling and prediction markets /s
it’s not that. see my other comment. the sponsorship makes me think it’s rigged, even if it actually isn’t. the perception is completely different now, to me anyway. but the sport has always been corrupt lol
Clown comment that misses all the points on purpose
even if it’s not rigged or whatever, the thought is now permanently there with their gambling sponsorship
edit: meant to make this comment as my edit on the first comment
Adam Silver’s NBA
Theres 1:37 in the clock but this whistle killed us. The knicks were on the backfoot and minnesota had all the momentum
This is the second game of the season where a bad late call has screwed the wolves, really tiring to watch
If your the furthest away official, and absolutely noone is complaining on the floor, and the other two refs arent saying anything? Why are you blowing your whistle? Fire this guy.
He waits to see who gets the ball and blows the whistle as soon as Gobert comes up with it and passes it out
Because if the shot didn’t hit rim and was picked up by the Knicks, then it’s play on. If the shot doesn’t hit rim and gets picked up by the Wolves, then it’s a shot clock violation.
This isn’t meant to defend the call. That shot clearly hit rim. Just giving the reason why the ref would hold his whistle.
You’re absolutely right
Next level bullshit
Refs gamble man
The only defense of this is that maybe bridges could’ve closed out in time but otherwise hard to see how they didn’t steal a game tying 3
But Ayo shoots clearly after the whistle is blown. It looks like a practice 3.
yea it was wrong to just stop the game, but the game clearly did stop before he shot his body language was def practice 3
The whistle goes off before he even catches it, while ball is still in Rudy’s hands. Sucks but play was dead dead.
Ayo is still shooting 45 percent from three this season. It’s not like it was lucky that it went in
Bridges had his back turned and momentum was carrying him away from the play.
I agree
The whistle goes off while ball is still in Rudy’s hands tho.
No team has been screwed more by refs more this year. This and the Cavs game gives us atleast 1 more win (factoring in ot this game and possibility of ant missing a free throw in the Cavs game).
Of course you would this game with just one whistle change