Tyrese Maxey’s one dribble dunk from the half-court line.
That was like a hundred steps lmao
Looks like 5 full steps post gather lol
yup, idk the rule about the first as he’s picking it up but putting the streamable in slowmo, there’s definitely 4 full ones after that
uhhh that can’t be right, can it?
why do we even bother with rules lol
If you count his gather as when he puts his second hand on the ball then he only takes 2.
The problem is he definitely got too under the ball prior to that. Hypothetically if he high dribbles to take the same amount of time while not getting under the ball then this is clean.
ahhh i didn’t realize the steps with one hand on were counted differently. if thats what you’re saying?
honestly i have never really understood what the gather rule really is. so you get a couple bonus steps with one hand on the ball basically?
Laughed seeing it live
The fact that it’s Maxey makes it so much funnier. That fact that he’s always grinning like a kid that just got away with something, it’s too perfect.
It was only 2 steps after he finished gathering but another 3 steps while blatantly carrying during his gather.
Idk I legitimately count 4 steps after the gather after slowing it down, plus 3 or 4 steps during the “gather.”
This shit is beyond ridiculous at this point.
I remember a few years ago when Robert Covington had a crazy travel that not a single person acknowledged lol. Caught a pass in the corner, pump faked a defender, and then just side stepped without dribbling at all. No whistle, commentators said nothing, no crowd reaction and no highlight posts later. Thought I was going nuts, lol.
you absolutely do not get to count the steps while the ball was bouncing and not in his hand. in no point in the NBA was that a thing that you’d do.
Carrying is a gather technically they just never enforce carrying
Carrying can only happen between dribbles, so the moment you think the carry started is actually the gather. Here’s the official language, along with the thing you described as the start of a “carry” that was an actual gather:
For a player who is in control of the ball while dribbling, the gather is defined as the point where a player does any one of the following:
Puts two hands on the ball, or otherwise permits the ball to come to rest, while he is in control of it;
Puts a hand under the ball and brings it to a pause; or
Otherwise gains enough control of the ball to hold it, change hands, pass, shoot, or cradle it against his body.
Maxey did all three of these things and took about 5 steps afterward.
For reference, here’s the carry language:
A player who is dribbling may not put any part of his hand under the ball and (1) carry it from one point to another or (2) bring it to a pause and then continue to dribble again.
A carry is technically just a failed gather!
By current NBA officiating, this is correct.
Putting your hand underneath the ball is a gather. A gather doesn’t require both hands. A gather is picking up your dribble. So if you put your hand underneath the ball and take two steps, you’re not supposed to get another two steps when you put your other hand on the ball.
You can gather with one hand when it starts to carry (hand comes underneath the ball). So it was 3 steps after the gather.
But it wasn’t 4 or 5 steps like other people think.
It was a gather, crab dribble, and then a euro so actually it’s all good
Lmao
It’s pronounced Lamelo, friend
Don’t forget the ghost step
A Euro travel which doesn’t count in america.
I think the most maxey favorable interpretation is 3 steps post gather step.
That’s the problem though.
A comment in the earlier Lamelo travel highlighted it.
When does he lose the ability to continue his dribble?
With the gather-step being codified, all the onus falls on when a player has finished their dribble and continuing would be a carry.
But in today’s NBA, there is no carry. Hand fully under the ball for long stretches which puts the defender in the impossible position of guarding against the triple threat (should be reserved for when you’ve picked up your dribble or are yet to dribble) at the pause after every dribble.
Pausing every dribble while being able to shoot, pass, or keep dribbling is stupid. You see players extend the ridiculousness of their carry as a way to freeze and surprise defenders, and it’s just never called.
So in this play, who can say when they would call a carry? The ball sits in that position players abuse for many of the steps. If it’s not a carry, then it’s probably not a travel.
But it’s obviously a travel. And so it’s obviously a carry, but that means the NBA needs to change what gets called as a carry.
I counted 6-7, but you always have to keep in mind the “gather”.
The morons that call Sixers games showed it 4-5 times only commenting on Maxey being opportunistic.
So six steps traveling? Don’t care what anyone says about the gather step. It was created because professionals couldn’t stop traveling, which is sad.
8 total from the last dribble. At some point we need a clear dribble step without the nonsense. Like 2 steps per dribble max.
it’s actually only 3 steps after the gather. The gather occurs either 1) both hands touch the ball or 2) a single hand carries the ball.
His left hand came underneath the ball when he was at the 3 pt line. Then he took 3 steps after that, so it’s a travel.
It was one extra step
Which one?
The last one definitionally. He gathers last step outside the arc and takes three steps inside the arc. You are allowed two, therefore he took “one extra step”
I dont think you know what the gather is, was just 2 steps
I dont think you know what steps is
I don’t know if I can give the ref a pass on this one, lol. He stopped dribbling well before he even got to the 3 point line.
What are you talking about lmao. There is nothing to miss. Its an open and shut case. Travel. No gather step shenanigans. Travel. Yall NBA ball apologists are insane.
Yup. As soon as his right hand went under the ball to carry it, the ball was gathered.
Traveling and carrying might as well not exist in the modern nba with how it’s called lol
Which sucks because that’s one of core rules that makes basketball hard. If you can just have infinite steps without bouncing the ball then there is 0 chance the player fucks up the dunk/layup (unless it’s Rudy Gobert). And if you can carry the ball it don’t matter how good of a defense they are playing you can always just invent some bullshit to save yourself from getting stripped.
infinite steps
We already have this sport, it is called Lacrosse
Lacrosse rules
thats more like hockey tbh
Thats part of what made Giannis unstoppable. He would carry/travel lower his shoulder and just truck his way to the rim, and a defensive foul would be called.
It’s genuinely so hard watching him. Its only gotten worse as the years have gone by and he gets away with it more so he does it more and more egregiously
League wants the highlight more than sticking to the rules
Yeah, the modern hesi is total bullshit that’s impossible to defend.
Isn’t that how Shai gets a lot of buckets? Bro just switches his pivot foot whenever, and then NBA posts it like some highlight while conveniently hiding his foot with a caption text box.
My dad only watches women’s basketball. We watched South Carolina vs SoCal and he was calling out travels that the NBA would have given 2 extra steps on.
WNBA has their own fair share of reffing problems even if traveling calls ain’t one.
South Carolina vs SoCal would be NCAA, not WNBA
Handball is now one of the 4 major pro sports in the US. I think if they start training now, a team of NBA players could medal in Handball at the 2028 Olympics
They still have to dribble after 3 steps unlike the clip we just watched.
That’s why they need to start training now
Handball?
Maybe it’s just a coast thing
Haven’t seen any leagues or what have yous here in Minneapolis
r/woooosh
Don’t even get me started on palming.
Makes players unguardable. They go under the ball so guys get closer, then off they go. Ja Morant is the queen of this
I feel like I see both called regularly in our game, and I usually agree except for the fact that highlights like this exist
Dude wanted to meet Parthanax, he took Seven Thousand Steps.
His name is Partysnax dude
His name is Mario
He taught me the best thuum.
“Hhere Wii Goh”
Shameful even in an All-star game.
It was 99 gather steps.
Gather isn’t complete until the player feels comfortable with their grip on the ball
Take one down pass it around !!!!!
But a bitch wasn’t one
I love Maxey but he was ready to skip all the way home
Yeah but it’s gonna go crazy on the Kia™️ Travel the World™️ Travel Cam that gets posted to Bleacher Report, subscribe now! 🤑🤑🤑
They like traveling, they like sponsorships, and they like slowing the game down for replays.
Why not stop the game for a travel, watch a bunch of replays, and then see if a travel or car company want to sponsor the travel? Then they can decide to call the travel or not based on whether it’s sponsored?
It also corresponds to the concept of stars being allowed to do things role players can’t.
Giannis with another travel, sponsored by Jeep. Count the basket.
Mf travelled to the moon and back
This man traveled from here to Europe and back.
99 steps and a dunk
Look at that smile he knows he got away with murder
He took 3 full steps after his hand was completely under the ball
Is traveling even against the rules in the NBA anymore lmao
The Maxey Marathon dunk
THANK YOU! I couldn’t believe it when I saw it live and the commentators said nothing about it! The amount of carrying and traveling that Maxey and Brown do drive me crazy lol
Egregious travel lmao
That one step was 13 steps?
76 of them
All gather step(s)… lol
Somebody said he had 30 points and 115 all purpose yards.
In the modern NBA traveling does not exist
First step, second step, gather step, euro step, pivot step, 1-2 step, 12-step program…
Finished with 12 points, 8 rebounds, and 15 rushing yards.
It’s actually two steps. The gather is when his hand is behind the ball, he is already taking a step when that happens and that is the 0 step, then he just does 2 step. At most you can argue it’s 3 if you think he already gathered by the time he does the step 0 I mentioned, but I don’t think he did. Look, you might not like the rules, or you might not understand them, but this is not a travel and if it is it’s barely one.
I think it’s 8 steps. Fucking batshit insane.
Steps 1-5: Clearly during the dribble.Steps 6-9: Steps during the gatherSteps 10-11: Close but part of the layup making them reasonable stepsStep 12: Likely didn’t actually touch the ground because Maxey is that good
According to today’s rulebook: if you carry the ball sideways it’s obviously not a carry, and it’s obviously impossible to gather without two hands on the ball. Nothing wrong with this play.
That’s not a travel, that’s a vacation
Dude went on sabbatical
Guy retired early to explore the world for the rest of his life
Full on government shutdown on that drive. The whole arena staff had been furloughed.
First time i lol’ed onine in awhile bruh. Nice.
He got 1000 air line miles on his credit card with all the traveling.
That’s not a travel, that’s itinerant nomadism.
If he traveled any further it’d be called a holiday
If there’s a natural disaster that’s a Ted Cruise
He didn’t travel, he used “summer” as a verb
there was enough time for someone to drive a car out there for him to jump over
A couple more steps and it would have been a leave of absence
This clip is from the book Around the World in 80 Days.
I just can’t watch the NBA anymore, this ruins it for me.
Jet2Holiday
That’s a blue origin orbit around the equator
That’s globetrotting.
2 pts 1 stl 15 yards rushing
Can’t believe Randle missed that tackle
Maxey is known to be an elusive back, he’s been a top 10 RB this season because of his missed tackle rate. Great 2nd round pick
Randle took out Brown later, tho.
nice stuff arm on vj too
Randle is more like nba equivalent to metcalf
After 2 days of pointless hip drop discussion, it’s nice of Tyrese to do something to bring the community together.
a hip drop is when
listen you can’t be out here doing a hip drop
Doing gods work
I wanna say Eagles could do a lot worse for their RB7. But Howie would just send him to green Bay for a 2028 3rd
more than Derrick Henry last night
(am a Ravens fan it hurts every Sunday)
Best run Philadelphia’s had all year
everyone talking about the arm push off thing on offense, but this league would change overnight if they actually enforced dribbling and travelling rules.
1 backbord
Should I target maxey or rhamondre on waivers?
Maxey might inline for more touches this week
Blatant travelling. The NBA is a joke now
Frodo took less steps
One does not simply gather step into Mordor. The paint is guarded by more than just a center. There are referees there that do not whistle, and their great eye sees nothing. It is a congested lane, riddled with help defense, charges, and flopping, the very foot you pivot is always moving. Not with a stutter step and a euro could you do this. It is a turnover.
Have you heard nothing Lord Silver has said? The highlight must be posted.
One does not simply gather step into Mordor.
Or maybe that was the trick all along.
Wish I could upvote this multiple times. I see you
Fewer
Fewer took less steps
It’s Pippin that is a Took
A fool of one at that
When you consider the stride difference I think both are correct.
negative
I hate this nitpick because it’s not even more correct historically. Less was originally used for both countable and uncountable. The distinction was arbitrarily proposed later.
Well it’s the standard for the time we are living in
What standard? People now still use less for countable things all the time.
Tyrese Mannis
Every step that Maxey took on this drive was the furthest he’s ever been from home.
Can confirm
Forrest Gump took less steps
I’ve determined Maxey is Frodo with VJ as Sam. Brown and Embiid are Legolas and Gimli respectively and Lebron is obviously Gandalf lmao
https://youtu.be/DgMnCLHQuqc?si=nmmSZIx0Xd5ezwyV
Man at this point just make a it an official rule that if you have a clear path and you go for a cool dunk there’s no traveling. It’s basically already a rule
lol would love a ref calling a travel only cause they weren’t impressed
Make it a tech lol
Normal dribble rules and non cool dunk: Fine
Crazy travel dunk and you don’t VC that shit? Flagrant Foul
I’m imagining the Tony brothers face as he walks to the mic to announce that shit was weak
Upon further review, that dunk was pretty wack. Number 0 will receive a technical foul and we will all now point and laugh.
A player argues and he just claps real hard at them
Bill Kennedy would be even funnier
Believe it or not? Straight to jail
You joke, but if refs were told they could T people up for taking too many steps, they’d happily call travels a lot more. Prolly overcorrect even.
15 yard penalty, dunk was not cool enough
And 2 minutes in the box for no tomahawk
“Upon review, the dunk has been rescinded, and a technical foul is called for wasting my goddamn time with that weak shit.”
“Foul - number 0, lame ass dunk after 5 steps”
They make you sub out and sit on the bench with a dunce cap.
Delayed after the made dunk, like the fouls that get called only after the shot misses, but the exact opposite.
“Technical, wack-ass finish”
Lmao, ‘technical foul because I gave you 6 steps and you just dropped in a lame layup’
“Traveling; dunk wasn’t dope enough.”
Upon review, we have overruled the previous judgment and determined the dunk to be cringe.
I would love for it to be challenged, reviewed, and then the ref goes on the mic and says “it just didn’t do anything for me”
Dunk wasn’t sick enough, three free throws to the opposition.
As silly as this sounds i wouldn’t hate it as an actual rule
That’d be lit tbh
“Bitch! Get your ass to the bench! You get a 5 minute technical for bouncing around like you’re Bob Sacre. The hell is the matter with you?”
‘49’
watch a center do a gather step awkwardly. they will call it a travel.
Yeah but then we need judges on the sideline giving the dunk a score and it’s gotta be a 45 or better. This right here was so weak. Should be a flagrant 1 if they get the steps but then do trash ass dunk like this
I’m here for it and the league should be too. Longer game and more theatrics increases entertainment for the fans and allows for more commercial time. I’m going to contact Commissioner Silver right now and give him the good news. I’ll make sure all credit goes to u/bonergainz.
Lmao calling out his username made me laugh more than anything else in this thread… and it’s a funny ass thread.
Silvers wet dream
If they are anything like the dunk contest judges, they can get a 45 from a layup.
Flagrant 2 if they biff a weak dunk.
judges are people picked at random from the 400s
dont let dwayne wade be a judge again dear god
Or just Shaq with a camcorder.
I actually think this kind of stuff should be enforced. There’s nothing more exhilarating than dunking off a fast break before a defense can get to you, yes, but being able to travel makes it completely unstoppable. If you can’t push a dribble ahead of you enough to coordinate a dunk like this without slowing down then I dunno what to say.
This maxey dunk animation was far too default to even remotely justify it, but even if he had windmill jammed it or something, the long distance commute would have distracted from it anways
Windmill slam on these should be a minimum
Except he didn’t do a cool dunk.
Travel!
ya this is ridiculous.
either make it a rule or start calling this BS. It wasnt even a cool dunk. Even it it were, it just looks stupid imo
i mean it’s a clear path. i’d be fine if he did a windmill or 360. but to just do a standard dunk that most 6’ college rec players can do….. call the travel. rule of cool. if ur just doing that then dribble the ball.
But in order to do something like that you do not need 10 extra steps.
My suggestion would be allow one extra step in that situation. One
You gotta draw the line somewhere. That’s plenty for a dunk. Save that stuff for the dunk contest
This wasn’t even a cool dunk. It was just a dunk lol
Thank you!
The thing that irritates me the most is guards will do stuff like this, and gather step hop back pull up 3s and no whistles ever… but a big man tries to post up and gets bumped off his spot, travel every time. The rules are not even applied to our big clunkers.
Yeah the NBA rules highly disadvantage bigs
Bigs arent flashy, they dont sell shoes well, they dont make as good clips. Its so annoying cus they really have fucked them over. I wouldn’t want to be a big man in todays nba like how JJJ and ayton and AD dont want to do center things.
Expected to do all the dirty work, get mauled by anyone more than 2 inches shorter with no calls, called much stricter for their fouls, barely get any touches, and people make fun of you if you get toasted by a guard who gets to carry and travel. Id want to play like a guard and be a stretch 4 too
But your team loses points if you biff it or your dunk is lame.
Judges gotta rule it at least a 6
It’s called the rule of cool
I thought it was AI for a second, it’s so cartoonish watching this play.
Honestly yeah this would rock and you are right refs never call it anyway and let it happen already
It wasn’t even a cool dunk.
Something something Idiocracy something something documentary. Something about SlamBall as well.
The Rule of Cool.
Old head’s heads gonna explode
I’m not complaining lol
Internet should get to vote on the score and if it’s a 8 or higher then no travel should be called
Rule of cool
Scale the points awarded to the cool factor. Maximum 5 points, but if you pull a lame ass dunk, you get a point deducted. Points are retroactively adjusted after the final buzzer for maximum chaos.
5 points is the soft cap for uncontested dunks. More for height disadvantage vs closest defender. Yuki Kawamura pulls an East Bay over Wemby = catching the golden snitch
What happens when you miss the windmill?
This wasn’t even a cool dunk. Should be a tech for the travel and weak WNBA style dunk.
This is only acceptable if you do some 360 through the legs or something. Otherwise this should be a travel and a tech for disrespecting the game.
Rule of cool or GTFO.
You gotta make it sexy. This is Roller Girl we’re talking about.
Nips and hips, make it sexy or we don’t eat
Was just thinking it’s been a long time since someone did a 360 dunk during a game. Kobe and T-Mac used to do them every now and then during a game. Crazy to think about now
We’re already so far gone when it comes to travels that they might as well
Mandatory entry in the next dunk contest where you have to replicate the dunk. Fined $10k for every point below 50 you score.
Obi doesn’t even travel to drop eastbays on people. No excuse for this
Watch out, you’ll get modern “ballers” here arguing how it’s boring that we try to adhere to the rules of fucking BASKETBALL.
These refs have no respect.
That’s not a travel that’s a journey
a pilgrimage
A haj
Sorry I don’t Arabic
clutch Scrabble word
Except, like this misspelled comment, there is only one J in Scrabble.
He’s going to Zanarkand.
pilgRIMage
An odyssey.
Our age of hardwood is collapsing
We’ve betrayed Naismith’s law
A space odyssey. Homie trekked to the stars on that shit.
Out now on streaming platforms
I promise I’m not AI 👀
not just any odyssey, space odyssey.
they should make a parody of SpaceJam with this and call it Space Odyssey
I couldn’t tell if that was Tyrese Maxey or Zheng He.
Buddy should take a bike next time
Now that Oubre is off the team someone has to.
dawg that’s an odyssey
Matt Damon went to Mars and back on fewer steps
It’s the AA of dunks.
12 step.programne.
An expedition
There n back again n shit
The Neverending story
That’s 40 years in the desert.
The fact that this is even a question anyone would ask, let alone debate, is proof of how far removed we are from anything approaching common sense.
“Yeah, well, you see, he floats the ball here, and then he initiates his gather ste—”
No. Shut the fuck up. This is a travel. It’s clearly a travel. It should be clear to anyone older than fourth grade who has ever picked up a basketball.
He literally takes 6 steps after his last dribble. The league is cooked.
Even in my most generous of gather step granting, it’s a clean 4 steps after the gather. So obvious.
The commissioner is out to lunch
Maybe he is out to China.
looked like thirty
Do you know the rules of the game? You started counting steps at the wrong moment
Okay let’s review the rules. It’s considered gathered when you have a hand under the ball or you bring the ball to a stop and have enough control to dribble/shoot. 2 steps outside of the 3 point line he cradles the ball and has full control. That’s his gather and his dribble is dead. He then takes 2 steps, puts the ball in the both hands and takes an additional 2 steps. That’s 4 steps after his dibble is no longer live. That’s a whole ass travel under even the most generous reading of the rules and accounting for a zero step.
Youre the only person you actually replied showing they understand the rule. Thank you!
I counted 3 steps after gather, but 4 steps after gather is also a reasonable interpretation. Definitely a travel, but not 6 steps.
No, the refs don’t know the rule of the game. If they didn’t let players carry the ball when gathering then this would be called for the travel it is. They let the players carry as they take all the gather steps and only start counting the 2 steps once they put both hands on the ball. His hand was fully under the ball.
You’re missing an /s
Like I read on another subreddit. Can’t remember which one…
“Finished with 21 points and 115 rushing yards.”
Watching video my thoughts were
oh he’ll bounce it again
he’ll jump now surely
I’ve lost count of steps he’s taken since he bounced it
Why is this even a discussion
Perfect summation. I was prepared for a soft cary or something borderline. Instead we got to watch a man run 80 feet bouncing the ball twice
It’s a discussion because of the ref staring right at it and swallowing his whistle.
My first thought was “this has to be AI”.
Don’t believe your lying eyes.
My issue aside from the blatant lack of calls for this kind of thing is all the casual dopes with their most skilled bestest super duper era stuff.
It’s sad to think about how the number of people who believe LaMelo Ball is better than Magic Johnson is greater than two (LaMelo himself and LaVar). You know there are people out there who believe that.
It’s not a genuine question, it’s engagement bait. Don’t think you’d find many people genuinely defending these clips.
Well, the refs are defending this clip. And right now their opinion means a heck of a lot more than yours. Perhaps this issue needs extra engagement so the people with the power to change it do change it.
I would buy that if not for the countless other similar examples that always draw out defenders. And the fact that the NBA doesn’t call these.
But yeah, you’re right that the original video and caption is engagement bait.
Clearly engagement bait bro. Just try to use ur head a lil more ⏸️
I don’t think you can tell if it’s a travel from this clip. The video is too blurry to see if the dribble is still live before he puts his second hand on the ball, and you can’t tell from this angle if his hand is under the ball or not. If the ball is still spinning in the air before he gathers it, and his hand didn’t go under before then, it’s not a travel. There’s no limit to how many steps you can take between bounces of the ball. I wish people could be impressed by a player’s speed in these videos before getting up in arms about traveling when it’s not as clear as it seems to those who haven’t read the rules for themselves.
I think even Tyrese knew he got away with it.
You just insulted a bunch of third graders who probably know the game of basketball than those officials. NBA is garbage.
the confusion is likely because they aren’t aware that the 2009 rule change only allowed for a single zero step; they may believe your steps are uncounted until the ballhandler has gathered the ball.
if you count him as gathered when his second hand hits the ball, then he only took two steps after gathering… the issue tho is he took like 5 zero steps lol
The issue is that carrying is allowed. He’s got his hand fully under the ball for those 5 “gather steps.” If they started calling carrying when the hand was half way under the ball, all this “gather step” stuff would be impossible.
He does it after the first dribble too
that is a good point
The ball was gathered when he was two steps outside of the 3 point line. He has full control of the ball and a hand under it.
i don’t disagree. it’s a travel in either interpretation.
Specifically how many steps did he take based on the nba rules?
2 steps outside of the 3 point line he cradles the ball and has full control. He takes 2 steps, then brings his other hand up to grab the ball with both and takes 2 more steps into a dunk.
Whatever the rules say about gather step. They just need to change it back to two steps period. Might as well be football in a hoop at this point
travels for days
1 dribble from the opponents 3 pt line
Game played so fast, refs look for injury based faults, not travels. They literally watch the ball, not the feet.
I don’t follow basketball as closely as I use to… do opposing coaches or players or anything even bother complaining to the refs anymore? Is it it just so assumed that you can do what the fuck ever that even the other team just accepts it?
There has to be some bozos who think it isn’t a travel.
The floating ball thing just totally ignores gravity too. Shit is still being manipulated by the hand. Taking infinite steps because it is still a “live dribble” is so dumb. If the ball is off the floor, you should never be able to take two steps regardless of context. I hate gather dribble and floating ball combo rule.
If we look at where the refs are on the court when he traveled we would understand why it wasn’t called.. that play happened pretty fast ref was just in a bad spot cause Maxey is so effin fast
He traveled sooo much that he went to the hotel, grabbed his bags, and was on his way back to Philly BEFORE the dunk!
yeah we have lost the plot at this point
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rage-baiting
Yeah well you see, he floats the ball at the start, then initiated his gather step, then the ball guides him forward, he changes hand to the guiding ball, jumps and scores. All justified.
His hand is under the ball and he’s cradling it , that’s considered a complete gather by the nba rules
I truly do not care about any technical arguments anyone presents, this is simply bullshit, full stop.
This is one of those all to common NBA clips that actively put me off the game. In the same way bad officiating clips makes me not want to watch the NFL, clips like this make me not want to watch NBA
Yes it’s getting really bad.
If I were to do this in some pickup league for just random guys, I would know it was a travel, everyone would know it was a travel, nobody would fight it. We’d laugh and be like ‘Man, that was a fucking journey’. But it’s just allowed all too often in the NBA now.
When Steph retires I’m out, all the top players are foul baiters and everyone travels.
Might tune in for the Wolves and Ant man but that’s it. Warriors will be ass cuz Lacob thinks our success is due his brilliance not Steph and Kerr
Warriors ain’t exactly a moral compass to follow lol, the moving screens are just as egregious
And Draymond is one of the most dirty players of the last 15 years.
I’m talking about excitement not morality. And everyone does moving screens the warriors just had the ability to hit shots
People who try to rules lawyer this shit are the same ones who think you’re morally allowed to do literally anything so long as it’s technically legal.
While I kinda agree with you here, it’s funny comparing this to conversations about rules in football.
Football coaches and players are praised for being like “Oh yeah this looks weird, but according to page 157, paragraph 3, subsection 3.C.b you’re actually allowed to do this”.
“The age of consent in this state is 16! Yeah, I’m 45, but that doesn’t matter, it’s legal!” Sure, it’s legal, but you’re still a disgusting piece of shit and a pedophile.
Yeah but to make it analogous to this clip the girl is 12 and the cops are watching the 45 year old perform despicable acts with her but do nothing.
Sounds like Ted Nugent’s song and dance
Society stands on the shoulders of the moral multitudes who don’t permit themselves to act immorally just because a temporary government signed off on it.
I wish. Someone should tell or current society that. Even worse, these days it’s not the temporary government that they look to for approval. It’s tiktok and Instagram influencers. Sad days
Um… technically ☝️🤓
So we should call fouls based on if we don’t like the play, even if the player didn’t break a single rule?
Tell me how you really feel. ;)
What does that mean
People trying to argue ‘their feelings in any given moment’ instead of ‘explicitly defined and written rules’ are… questionable.
You’re arguing against the concept of the spirit of the law. This is a common tactic among deeply immoral people.
Literally pointing out the actual rule is… immoral now? Moral basketball is ‘my guy wins’ i take it.
That’s not what he said, those are words you put in his mouth.
“How is this allowed?”
“No don’t use the rule book!”
Yes, but unironically. Because the rules of NBA basketball weren’t handed down by god. They aren’t unassailable. So the obvious implied question is “why have the stewards of NBA basketball allowed this once great game to become a farce?”
By what process could the stewards of nba basketball disallow something, without using the rule book?
This is a travel and a missed call with the rules as they currently are. Period.
The way the NBA officiates the gather is that if its legal to take a dribble you havent gathered yet. In this clip the nba doesnt think he gathered until he has 2 hands on the ball, because carrying no longer exists. After that he takes 2 steps. The league needs to start enforcing carries for this to go away
Dont worry even if we bring every rule : gather etcc its still bullshit haha
This is exactly how I feel. We all know a travel when we see it and this gather step bullshit needs to stop
Nah even with the technical arguments it’s still wild. Dude had the ball palmed from damn near half court and ran with it.
I feel like only Wemby and Giannis should get away with the one dribble fastbreak, it just looks wrong seeing a guard do it
I mean Giannis is a pretty bad offender. And that’s coming from someone who lived in Milwaukee for a time and always followed him and liked him.
Do you understand the rule?
It’s a carry. His hand was under the ball and he took 3 steps.
The only “technical” argument someone could make is that he only took 4 steps + a gather step. There is no world where that’s not a travel or a carrying
Who are you arguing against?
He has a huge smile on his face because he knows he traveled
Man jumped off his right leg because he must’ve noticed that he’d already taken 6 or steps and thought it was too risky to go for one more.
Jumping off your right leg on the left side of the rim is about the only thing worth praising in this clip. Bad joke dude.
because he’s Tyrese Maxey
Bro didn’t travel, he went on a journey
He took a whole-ass gap year.
He became an emigrant
Looks like he held up a ✌️ as well, like “two steps” LOL
I know traveling calls are rare in the NBA, but traveling as egregious as this should be called lol. I don’t think that’s too much to ask.
6ers fan and Maxey Stan, I’d even go as far as deduct the basket from the post game
I count 6. How many gather steps do you get again?
If you argue that he didn’t have control of the ball, I counted four where he held his hand under the ball while running. Before he ‘lost control’ he also had minimum one step over a gather. I’d argue that one was two steps past what’s allowed and the second travel was six.
Dribbling is dead in the NBA. You can now make your way to the basket (one foot in front of the other) while holding the ball. No need to bounce it.
Harden and Giannis bending the rules to the point they broke and now everyone is doing it.
Let players start peanut punching
I think the reason they usually let these go is because it didn’t affect the play. It’s a one man breakaway so they just let it ride. I do wish they’d just call the rules all the time though. Wouldn’t hurt him to dribble one more time on the way.
The NHL instituted a challenge system for offside goals after Matt Duchene scored a blatantly offside goal that went uncalled.
If the refs are going to allow these blatent travels, allow the coaches to challenge and expose the blindness of the referees.
Its either a travel or the rules need to be changed because this isn’t basketball. I was going to compare it to the Globetrotters but they show more ballhandling skill when they put on a show.
You’re right, just as the meat at McDonald’s is not meat: it’s essentially Pink Slime Product.
This is “Generic NBA Product”. If you want basketball, check out the Olympics and FIBA on YouTube.
It becomes a lot easier to enjoy the game when you accept this. And it’ll never change back to the way it was, so you have no choice.
Pink slime is meat
It’s the classic gather step crab dribble
Yup, this will ruin the League. If the game doesn’t resemble the one played as kids, there is no point in getting to the league for the game.
he travelled more yards than derrick henry had rushing yards last night
It’s just crazy how you can apparently now bounce a ball once from the halfway line. What the absolute fuck is this. I really liked basketball years ago but I couldn’t watch this trash.
One time when I was a kid I had a dream where I just ran the length of the court without dribbling and got away with it without the refs noticing
Believe it or not, totally legal now
It’s always been that way for the popular players. Heck, I remember in varsity volleyball, this kid that was like 7 foot tall on the other team was like catching the ball with his fingertips then aiming and flicking it back and no amount of trying to get the refs to do something did anything. So, I do it and like a quarter second later there’s the whistle.
It shouldn’t be, it looks so egregious lol
Welcome to the league or some stupid shit
russell_westbrook_inbound.mp4
Tyrese, is that you?
I played basketball in elementary school and one time this kid grabbed a board, ran to the half court line without dribbling whatsoever, and then, with the most ebullient smile on his face, hurled it as hard as he could and completely air balled it. Little did he know these plays would become standard fare in thirty years.
That dream is now the NBA
Well, the pre gather, the gather, the post gather, the crab, and then the euro. i guess its ok … says every nephew
The gather is a pretty clear rule. He gathered as soon as his hand was under the ball and it was in control, then took an additional 4-5 steps, should’ve been a travel.
Yeah the refs somehow got the idea that the ball can’t be gathered until both hands are on it. Players caught on and are really abusing it now. This and the lamelo one are completely egregious
Yep, as far as the refs are concerned he started gathering, took three steps during the process, finished his gather with both hands, took two steps, and dunked. But as soon as his hand went under the ball that should have been his gather step, so it would have been gather and then four steps, a clear travel if the refs called it right.
I guarantee no NBA ref would say this isn’t a travel. A missed call on an open dunk does not mean they think the gather rule allows for 4 or 5 steps post gather.
Nah the problem is actually that the gather is completely unclear.
It shouldn’t exist!
It’s not really; the refs just refuse to call carries. The moment his hand goes under the ball, it’s gathered.
What is not clear about it? It is subjective in a way but I feel that the rule makes sense.
https://official.nba.com/new-language-in-nba-rule-book-regarding-traveling-violations/
Definition of the Gather
The following definition of the gather will be added to the definitions section of the playing rules:
a. For a player who receives a pass or gains possession of a loose ball, the gather is defined as the point where the player gains enough control of the ball to hold it, change hands, pass, shoot, or cradle it against his body.
b. For a player who is in control of the ball while dribbling, the gather is defined as the point where a player does any one of the following:
This is the exact NBA rule. To be clear, I can’t see it in this video well enough and I’ve only watched the one angle, but in many circumstances, like the Hugo Gonzalez dunk a few weeks ago, the players are basically letting the ball spin in their hand, while they keep moving.
This allows them to extend their gather period to multiple additional steps.
This is the part that is not clear due to the exact wording of the rules. The ball is never coming to rest or being brought to a pause.
Defensive three second violations are a pretty clear rule too.
Yah, the most generous I could be counted 4 hard steps after gather. realistically it’s like 5, and even then it’s like 8 or 9 from the last time the ball bounced back to its peak after the last time it hit the ground.
Preflight gather. If you regularly gather, it can save you a lot of time.
Probably felt bad after because of post gather clarity
what the hell are we even doing anymore. i still think 99% of dribbling is a carry/travel, and the 5+ steps is becoming more and more common. when does it stop even being basketball?
Its not even a real sport anymore, it’s sports entertainment. This would not have happened in FIBA.
This is why I’m a Lakers fan. NBA is not a real sport, it’s entertainment. It may not have reached the point of wrestling where it’s scripted (I know this is debatable to an extent), but it’s not like the other major sports. So if I’m going to watch, I might as well watch and be a fan of a team that gets plenty of media coverage and has fun stuff going on.
Carrying is even worse than travelling. I don’t think there’s a single guard in the league that doesn’t carry on practically every single dribble. It’s a rule that genuinely may as well be deleted from the rulebook.
About 2010… It’s entertainment now.
That’s all sports is now. Entertainment. It’s no longer about competitive individuals wanting to play a sport they’re good at amongst the other top level athletes.
You people are insanely delusional with your enlightened takes, these changes have not stopped it from being real competition
I’d never say it’s not competition, but I am saying that the lack of rule enforcement and changes have really changed basketball for the days of Magic/Bird/MJ etc. Outside of how scoring works, the game isn’t quite the same. Dribbling and footwork allowances are absurd. Defensive sensitivity, offensive fouls not being called and flopping have some disengenuous scoring increase. We will never similar series to the West Coast Lakers/Blazers/Kings series of the 90s/00s. They were physical and intense. Not 140 pt game shoot outs.
People are trying to make superteams. Bird and Magic wanted to beat each other, not be on the same team to beat everyone. They’ve specifically called out LeBron about this.
The playoffs are where it’s at
and yet there’s a noticeable difference. What happened to the game I love?
There’s entertainment and there’s whatever the fuck NBA is allowing players to get away with. The last FIBA tournament NBA players had to fucking learn actual basketball rules anew, because otherwise they would be called a travel on every second play.
About…Lebron being a champ? 😂
I think what gets under my skin the most is when people post side by sides of different eras saying “lOoK hOW SlOW 90s PlAYeRs Are” well yeah dude if they were allowed to just sprint 4-5 steps without dribbling they would be a lot faster. Don’t even get me started on pivot feet. It’s real easy to be twitchy and showy when both feet can do ballet without calls
“Look how goofy Magic Johnson ran”
Yeah he had to keep a hand over the top of the ball the entire time and despite that he was still insanely fast with the ball. Imagine if he got to dribble like Giannis and carry the ball from half court to the free throw line with one dribble
They want it this way unfortunately
Why I stopped watching…
I’ve seen running backs dribble more.
Whoa whoa whoa, actually only 96% are carries.
This sport has been a game of HORSE for a decade or two. Defense is pointless, you can’t be in the same building as someone shooting without getting a foul which has led to this stupid game where each team takes a turn shooting a 3. Traveling hasn’t been a rule since the 90s on top of that. It’s so dumb.
It’s stops becoming basketball immediately because this is what first time players do and you teach them to stop this.
I counted 5 steps.
You don’t know about the gather step stroll?
white mamba, hush
I’m more mad that no one in stands called it. Normally in an away game you see 4 or 5 fans make the signal.
What I don’t understand is why do the players not say anything?
Feel like this one gets whistled if wasn’t wide wide open lol
Definitely. I think they gave him a “showmanship pass” since he was wide open.
But he didn’t do anything flashy unfortunately.
But plenty of wide open uncontested dunks get missed…and they don’t get their basket automatically added anyway. Gotta stick with the rules. They are what they are.
That’s a terrible analogy lol
Because they dont want the refs to blow the whistle when they do it next.
Yup
Because they know they do the same thing.
it’s 0-0, this is literally the first basket of the game
So? Still a possession. Imagine it being ignored in any other basketball context than an NBA game.
I would not call this in an outdoor pickup game.
Fr like I’d be embarrassed
It was the first or second possession of the game, I think everyone was just like okay we all warming up right now idgaf including the refs lol
Nets don’t give af. Its pathetic.
The sidelines of good teams would be jumping up and down
They all want easier scoring so they get better stats and fatter contracts.
Because theyre all doing it, and also theyd be fined. Why would they?
They know he needed those miles for the prize!
Wtf i just saw? This was not called for traveling. At this moment i dont know why nba has referees, they are bad as fuck
Somebody has to control the game based on gambling odds
What happened to the sport of basketball
More pts = more “excitement” = more $$$
Technically, dribbling was originally against the rules as created by James Naismith…
And the ball was poked back up from a small hole at the bottom of a real basket.
Edit to say the NBA should re-adopt that. COMMERCIAL BREAK AFTER EVERY PLAY, WHAT WHAT!?!?
Nothing the refs just fuckin suck
It’s not the refs. Somehow over time your allowed to pick up your pivot door and then take another step off your other foot. Imagine if Hakeem would’ve been allowed to do this(unguardable). Imagine if Giannis had Hakeems footwork with today’s rules
you’re*
6, count them, six steps
LOOK 🫴 HOW THEY MASSACRED MY [sport] 🥺
Clearly the B in NBA stands for basketball-ish
Well…
Basketball is fine.. its the NBA that sucks.
How the fuck am I meant to teach my kids to play basketball when this nonsense, amongst many other poorly officiated rules, are what they’re going to grow up watching?
You can’t, basketball is dead, pack it up boys, it had a good run (before it dunked)
My hot take is the nba dies before the mlb. Which the mlb won’t be far behind. Basketball internationally is thriving. You know why? Look at the reffing in the Olympics. Watch an international game. If you watch an nba game directly after it isn’t the same game. I don’t enjoy watching a bunch of multi millionaire grown men throw tantrums and throw themselves on the floor. It’s a brutal product to watch.
MLB viewership has been increasing across every medium (TV, streaming and in-person) for several years now, and that’s just American baseball. The “MLB/baseball is dying” narrative isn’t based in reality.
It’s a put something on as background sport always now. I don’t know a single person who watches the mlb. That’s a dying sport. I’m telling you nba is first and mlb is next. Viewership numbers doesn’t equal a growing sport.
It really is. Not only are the fouls imperceptible to the viewers eye, foul baiting has become as much a part of the game as trying to score the way it was intended.
The fix seems relatively straightforward. If the player on offense makes an unnatural motion to provoke contact, no foul. Call flopping. Call more techs for whining.
Flopping and whining need to be the first things to go and flopping leads to a lot of whining.
tf are you talking? Baseball is in the best place it’s been in years. The NBA has been a disaster for a decade.
The NBA may never truly die but most casual fans don’t watch the games and most diehards hate the officiating and rules.
It can’t got on as it’s been going due to these factors.
Might as well go watch ballet
A conspiracy to re-invent the game but instead of that racist Naismith who stole the invention we can have the rightful owner of the patent (Jaylen brown) come forth and save the world.
Teach your kids FIBA rules.
NCAA also has its own ruleset and its closer to FIBA rules anyway, they use them at the Olympics and at most international tournaments anyway.
NCAA keeps the three pt line, length of game, foul limit, no defensive 3 seconds, alternative possession arrow vs jump balls.
NCAA differs by having 30s shot clock instead of 24.
NCAA is more strict than both FIBA and NBA for traveling rules. FIBA allows a zero step but NCAA doesnt. NBA allows a lot of weird shit like a step before the dribble, a gather step on top of your zero step etc.
Thats on top of the fact that your kid has a 0.000000000001% chance of playing NBA hoops at anytime in his life.
I’ve seen little kids jack threes like crazy. And it’s not like the coach can bench them, they’re all doing it.
The last time I watched a kids (11-12 y/o) basketball game, whenever someone would get a wide open layup they would dribble it from the key out to the 3 point line and shoot it. These kids have watched too many Steph highlights.
Also trust that your kid learning fundamentals will be able to deal with kids who have spent their lives practicing taking 9 steps when the church league refs are gonna call em every single time.
And this shit is spilling over into pickup games. I am seeing way more people get hurt with collisions than I ever have and it’s because all these people are trying to do the dumb extra steps that SGA and Harden and those guys do.
Now they are trying to do “euro step into a gather step into a spinning pivot to change direction then jump off the opposite leg” or whatever and at this level no one can tell where they are fucking going (even them half the time) so it’s just constantly elbows into people who weren’t expecting it or the ball handler himself getting rammed into because defender couldn’t predict where he was going.
What happened to doing a bunch of behind the back / through the leg dribbles and then pulling up for a fade away while yelling “Kobe!”? That never hurt anyone (physically).
Show them European hoops.
Just teach them to never stop gathering.
Move to Europe maybe
Make them watch Big3 exclusively, don’t even tell them about the NBA
Question as someone who has never watched Big3: which rules are different from the NBA, and/or which rules do they enforce more?
Related question: where the hell do you watch Big3?
I think it comes on like fs1 or some weird channel like that. It’s basically pro gusmacker, so 3v3 half court. I’m not sure if they’d allow this type of travel but since it’s half court, you never really get away from the defense anyway. It’s pretty physical too, and weirdly there are 4 point circles that are further out than the 3 point line
Are your kids so stupid that they’ll model their technique after this? If so, you probably shouldn’t have had them (and you probably have bigger issues)
You’re a sack of shit.
This was the most horrendous travel I have ever seen. Worst than LeMelo Balls from a few weeks ago. Yeah players carry all the freaking time and travel (3 steps in the paint) and I can’t help but be hyper aware of it cause it bothers me so much lol
At least he had a wide open path here (although they still should’ve called it). In the Lamelo travel he was actively being guarded by another player.
Watch college basketball instead. I haven’t watched the NBA in ages because of this stuff.
They have one job. That is why it’s hard for me to watch soccer bunch of pro athletes who get paid 10’s of millions of dollars and they fall on the floor and cry if a slight breeze hits them. Play your sport like a professional
But they’ll give you a tech for clapping
I have no love for the Boston Celtics and I think those calls are bullshit
And they’ll kick you out for passing the ball a lil too hard to the ref.
They’ll give you an offensive foul if the defender makes you bleed on ball somehow.
no, they’ll give Jayson Tatum a tech for clapping. everyone else is safe.
Tatum still has a long way to go before he can match the sheer hostility of Tim Duncan glancing at you.
NBA has to address this crap. Fine the refs or demote them or whatever when they let this shit go.
Refs are more leniant when fouls don’t generate a competitive advantage. That’s why Russ thought he could get away with his infamous inbound travel a decade ago. No one wants to see penalties when there isn’t even a defender in frame.
This shit, just like Russ’s, is way beyond the pale though.
They need to do something like you can only gather step from the 3 point line in, anywhere else on the court is a travel
Or here’s a crazy idea. Do away with the gather step all together. It’s bullshit and just a rule to allow players to be lazy.
This is like saying you should only lie when you’re under oath.
Or, just get rid of the rule.
Theres no in-between.
Ref was literally right there watching all of his every 5 steps
Hand under the ball should count as gathering. Side is normal. There’s a way to do this move without putting your hand under. These are the most talented basketball players they should be able to handle technicalities like this.
The problem is just leniency with carries translates to leniency with the gather step to be consistent. Like if he took a hard dribble right before he grabbed with two hands, that would technically be a double dribble but wouldn’t be called. So if that’s not called, then technically he doesn’t need to take that dribble and can just pick it up. So yeah definitely a travel but consistent until they lock in on carries.
Yeah it’s exactly like that Lamelo travel stepback where he carries it for a few steps
Yeah, hate when people don’t understand the gather and think everything is a travel, but he clearly had control of the ball when his hand was under the ball and then took 4-5 steps, should’ve been an easy call by the ref on this one.
Except refs rarely call palming or carrying so they don’t look for it.
Wouldn’t it only be a carry if he put the ball back down? I mean this is a pretty obvious travel, I’m sure the ref turned his brain off as it was a breakaway, it should’ve been called.
No, carrying violation has two parts.
“A player who is dribbling may not put any part of his hand under the ball and (1) carry it from one point to another or (2) bring it to a pause and then continue to dribble again.”
Maxey clearly violated the first section. But neither of these sections are regularly enforced in the NBA.
Yeah, agreed, most people don’t understand gather or travel rules, and get it wrong most of the time. However, this is a travel. He clearly has his hand under the ball, and it alters its trajectory. I get Maxey is super fast, as are most all NBA players, but the ref is right there and should have called this.
Yeah, I would argue the issue is not most of the gather step rules. They are actually fairly logical. The issue is they allow carrying.
If one reads the official rules on this, the problem here becomes somewhat obvious:
(1) Puts two hands on the ball, or otherwise permits the ball to come to rest, while he is in control of it;
(2) Puts a hand under the ball and brings it to a pause;
(3) Otherwise gains enough control of the ball to hold it, change hands, pass, shoot, or the player cradles the ball against his body.
I would say section 1 and 3 here are pretty straightforward. Two hands on the ball? Check. Permitting the ball to come to rest? Check. Holding the ball? Check. Changing hands?? Check. Passing/shooting? Yep. Cradling against the body? Also check!
Now we look at section 2… putting hand under the ball? Nice…wait. “AND brings it to a pause.”
The “and” here is highly problematic. It’s not just a float dribble issue where it’s “or bring the ball to a pause” because you palmed it or something. That would be understandable. The problem here is they allow your hand to be under the ball as long as the ball is spinning. So this has allowed the float dribble to evolve from letting the ball spin live with your hand to the side of it (technically legal pretty much in every era) to actually allowing your hand to be under the ball legally as long as the ball is not paused.
If “AND” was changed to “OR” in section 2, it would make significantly more sense with how people have historically understood carrying to work.
The sections about dribbling/carrying are somewhat opposed to the gather rules:
A player who is dribbling may not put any part of his hand under the ball and (1) carry it from one point to another or (2) bring it to a pause and then continue to dribble again
Technically this outlines a carry but since a “pause” is required for the gather, it’s very unclear at what point they define a “carry” to happen. There is no rules language that actually clears up this ambiguity.
So, technically, this is not a travel if the ball is still spinning in his hand. (Hard to tell from this angle.) It probably should have been called a carry, but they never call a carry, which allows the gather to be delayed much longer than normal.
If they called carries, this would be easy. But they reality is just the hand being under the ball is not enough to end your dribble. It either has to be “paused” or “carried” (with whatever random definition they use for carrying, which is not strictly defined in the rulebook.)
That said, if they started calling carries then guys like Brandon Ingram wouldn’t even be allowed to touch the ball. lol
Carry. He puts his left hand under the ball which stops his dribble, then takes 3-4 steps. The gather rule makes sense if they apply it correctly but when your hand goes under the ball, that’s the gather.
Edit: travel is probably the correct violation term. The important part is that his gather here should be when he puts his hand under the ball, not when he put 2 hands on the ball.
Yeah exactly, it’s gather plus 3 or 4 steps. I have to slow it down to frame by frame because I could never count this in real time
To me, he’s mid step when he cuts off his dribble. So does that half step count as the “gather” or is it the first full step after picking up the dribble? My understanding is that it’s the former.. which would mean 4 steps after the gather
I’m not sure the answer to your question for sure but I thought it was the other way. I had this as gather + 3, because if you look at that former step, his hand is still kind of on the side and I believe he could’ve put the ball down again for a dribble legally, meaning he hadn’t ended his dribble yet. But in between steps with both feet in the air, his hand comes under the ball, making that next foot to hit the ground the gather. Just my understanding tho.
Definitely a travel either way
It’s not a carry because he didn’t try to dribble again. It’s a travel
You’re right. Whatever the actual violation is called doesn’t matter much to me. When he put his hand under the ball, his dribble is dead and that should be the gather. He then takes 3-4 steps which is a travel.
100% agree, it’s a crazy non call. His hand goes under the ball, which means he’s gathered the ball, then he takes 3-4 steps.
Very obvious travel
Just had a discussion on a very similar play in a different sub. To be clear: I agree this should be a violation. Is it though, by the NBA’s current interpretation of the rules?
It’s my understanding that it’s not a gather until he puts both hands on the ball. It’s also my understanding that it’s a carry if he dribbles again after putting his hand under the ball - which he doesn’t.
So unless putting your hand under the ball counts as a gather - which I agree it should, but I don’t think it does currently - this is not a carry or a travel.
I feel like that can’t be right, because then guys could just run down the court with the ball in one hand.
Edit: just read up some more, the hand under the ball should count as a gather by current rules. The refs are just pretending his hand is on the side of the ball.
By your definition, if you never put your other hand on the ball, it’s never a travel. You can tuck it like Saquon Barkley and just truck it down the court and nobody can stop you.
It’s not my definition
NBA definition is when you gain control of the ball, it’s a gather. You can gather with one hand
Yep, that makes sense, thanks
The nba definition of gaining control of the ball doesnt include putting your hand under it though. Players do that basically every play and its never called. In this clip maxey can take another dribble until his second hand touches the ball and there would be no whistle.
You are wrong. It does. If you put your hand on the ball *and redirect it’s path, you are controlling it and it is a gather. I mean, have y’all never seen a one handed gather layup? Shit, it doesn’t even have to be under the ball technically since some players can palm the ball but palm underneath is just a good sign to look for
That’s just not true. There’s nothing wrong with your hand going under the ball, it’s what the ball does while your hand is under it that is the problem.
Just…. Think about it this way. Say the ball gets deflected or you get a pass that is going down towards your knees, so you naturally stop the ball with your hand under it and rotate your hand around to dribble it. Was that a gather? No, it was the opposite of a gather, you’re literally starting your dribble!
Here’s the actual rule.
“a dribbling player cannot put any part of their hand under the ball and carry it from one point to another, or bring the ball to a pause and then continue dribbling”
You see that and? That’s the important part a bunch of idiots miss. The rule doesn’t say you can’t put your hand under the ball, it says you can’t put your hand under the ball AND THEN carry it from one point to another. There’s nothing wrong with putting your hand under the ball..
When his hand goes under the ball, his dribble is dead. He then takes 3-4 steps after that. If you don’t count his hand going under the ball as killing his dribble, for whatever reason, then the next time he kills his dribble is when he puts 2 hands on the ball. He then takes 2 steps after that.
It’s not a carry for the sequence you’re referring to. Carry is a dribbling violation. Travel is a step violation.
You’re correct tho about the hand going under the ball being a gather. He can’t dribble again and can’t take more than 2 steps in amateur leagues and 3 steps in pro leagues (NBA/FIBA).
The carry rule is important here because it is the reason the league no longer considers hand under the ball a gather. Really the gather is just the moment when it would no longer be legal to take a dribble. Because carries no longer exist the league thinks maxey gathers when his second hand touches the ball in this clip. Before that he can freely take another dribble. If the gather was earlier than the leagues interpretation of the carry rule would be fucked.
NBA is a joke nowadays.
Eventually we’ll see somebody run the full length of the court with 1 hand under the ball and it won’t be a travel cause he’s still gathering 🤣
You don’t understand, bro, he’s really fast. He doesn’t have time to dribble. Those old heads who didn’t sprint down the court in two dribbles weren’t “respecting the rules of the game”. They were just slow losers.
They need to start nipping these types of plays in the bud.
Another thing I’ve noticed that drives me crazy is the amount of times players move/swap their pivot foot, or the take three steps after catching the ball to get in a triple threat stance. Darius Acuff does it a ton and they don’t call it (which I’m fine with)
Honestly I’d prefer them not calling stuff like that to giving them more stuff to nitpick and miss. I feel like if we went back to that they would be too subjective on if someone got shoved off their pivot foot and it’d just lead to more refball than if they don’t call it at all. Consistent calling is far more important than making the “correct” calls on those sorts of plays IMO.
I think it’s already too subjective. The rule is already set in stone and worked that way for like 4+ decades. Only reason it’s not called now is offense is catered to which means more highlights which means more engagement
Eh, I think it’s one of many rules that the NBA stopped calling, and the game adjusted to. Think about how many lane violations you could call on free throws. Think about how much a ball bounces off a player in a hustle situation just for them to pick it up and start dribbling with it (technically a double dribble per NBA rules). If you went back now, both sides of the ball would completely change in those situations, and I think the product would be worse off for it, offensively and defensively.
Agreed, especially for something like this. Nobody outside of Reddit sticklers wants refs to call traveling on a clear breakaway dunk
The game is about entertainment at the end of the day. In a normal situation ofc the refs should be calling travelling, but on a play like this where it’s obvious Maxey will score, let the guys travel a bit so they can try some kind of cool dunk instead of calling every single little ticky tack foul
I feel like the NFL went through like 10 years when nobody knows what the actual definition of a catch is. I think the NBA needs to go through that with traveling/carrying. I dont care if the rule allows for a gather step or whatever which is different than it was 50 years ago but it should at least define what that is and stick to it. The NBA has a lot of work to do on that
You say that like we know what a catch is now.
I think most of us are in agreement what a catch is unless it is our team involved.
Yeah. Fuck the Saints. And the Packers.
And the cowboys. and definitely the rams
Perhaps we’re on the verge of basketball’s version of when Football adopted the forward pass & it goes the opposite way & we just get rid of dribbling & the game turns into rugby, but you gotta dunk it in a basket to score.
I’d legit watch that. Rugby is dope. Basketball is dope. Why not both?
No one knows what a hold is either.
I feel like the NFL went through like 10 years when nobody knows what the actual definition of a catch is.
No, we knew what a catch was. You just had ten years of Cowboys fans coping in public over Dez not completing a catch. Yes, the old “football move” condition was clunky, but the only time anyone acted like “no one knows what a catch is” was in relation to the Dez incompletion which isn’t even close to a catch to any neutral observer.
That’s insane! They don’t even care no more
My boy traveled to Guatemala and got a burrito and came back for the dunk
It’s just routine 6-step layup. Chillax ppl
yeah this shit sucks and is embarrassing for the NBA. Can’t really call myself a fan anymore.
I thought this was gonna be some Wemby-lik3 giant steps but no, its just a blatant travel